When self-driving cars are forced to crash, whom should they hit?
FREE Catholic Classes
If a self-driving car is about to crash into a crowd, and it can only swerve to hit a baby stroller or a large man, whom should it decide to kill?
Boston, Mass., (CNA) - Questions like that were the focus of a massive global survey by researchers who say the results could help program autonomous vehicles to behave "ethically" in split-second, life-or-death scenarios.
Their paper, titled, "The Moral Machine Experiment," was published in the journal Nature Oct. 24. The researchers' internet platform, called the Moral Machine, asked participants to consider practical dilemmas autonomous vehicles might encounter in daily operation. Participants were asked their moral preferences about how an autonomous vehicle should respond in crisis situations- like whether to swerve to hit a crowd of people or stay on course to hit two people.
Commonalities among respondents included a preference for humans over animals, for the young over the old, and for preserving the lives of many people rather than a few people. Respondents also showed a moderate preference for sparing law-abiding bystanders over jaywalkers.
Among the authors of the paper was Iyad Rahwan, an associate professor of media arts and sciences at the MIT Media Lab.
"On the one hand, we wanted to provide a simple way for the public to engage in an important societal discussion," Rahwan said, according to the MIT News Office. "On the other hand, we wanted to collect data to identify which factors people think are important for autonomous cars to use in resolving ethical tradeoffs."
The paper discusses how these preferences can contribute to developing "global, socially acceptable principles for machine ethics," its abstract said.
For Stephen Barr, a Catholic scientist who is a physics and astronomy professor at the University of Delaware, the survey results show some merits.
"Favoring humans over animals is obviously right," he told CNA. He compared distinctions among humans envisioned in the scenario to "triage situations" in hospitals.
"Some of the rankings one finds in this survey make sense and are perfectly traditional. Others are a bit strange, such as disfavoring large people," he said.
While not necessarily endorsing the preferences, Barr said, "some rules must be given to the machines that reflect human moral judgments, and they must be the kinds of rules that a machine can apply."
"The rules people come up with for the machines to follow will not be perfect, but they may be better than the way a human driver in a state of panic would respond," he said.
The researchers' Moral Machine platform collected 40 million decisions in ten languages from millions of people around the world, in 233 countries and territories. Over 490,000 respondents gave demographic data, which researchers split to subgroups by age, education, sex, income and political and religious views.
The top six strongest preferences to spare a character in the scenarios, in descending order, were a baby stroller, a girl, a boy, a pregnant woman, a male doctor and a female doctor.
Respondents rated criminals of lower importance than dogs, who in turn were lower than an old woman, an old man, a homeless person, a large man, a large woman and a male business executive.
Researchers documented individual variations based on respondents' demographics, as well as cross-cultural ethical variation. Their analysis found three major clusters of differences, clusters researchers said "correlate with modern institutions and deep cultural traits."
The researchers categorized these clusters as "western," "eastern" and "southern."
Those in "southern" countries showed a stronger tendency to save young people over the elderly, while those in the "eastern" cluster, which included many Asian countries, showed a weaker tendency to save children instead of the elderly compared to the other two groups.
Catholic ethics generally hold there to be a natural law standard of ethics that transcends cultural groups.
Barr said that widespread moral preferences "can be in error" but by definition the natural moral law is not.
"But natural law is often reflected in very widespread and transculturally held moral ideas," he said. "The preferences for saving the child over the adult, the pregnant woman over other adults, the human being over the animal, and several other preferences seen in this survey are quite consistent with traditional Christian values and with the natural law."
Other preferences seemed arbitrary to Barr, such as the ranking for the large man.
"Since questions of the common good are clearly involved, ultimately public authorities must be involved in setting the rules," he said. "In one way or another, public opinion will play a large role, especially, but not only, in democratic societies."
If responsible people perceive the rules to be unreasonable, "they will not be tolerated for long."
Because public opinion can be influenced by various authorities, the Church "should do what it can to enlighten people on the principles that should apply," said Barr.
Copyright 2019 - Distributed by THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK
Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for January 2019
Young People and the Example of Mary. That young people, especially in Latin America, follow the example of Mary and respond to the call of the Lord to communicate the joy of the Gospel to the world.
The state of Montana is considering a bill that would criminalize revenge porn - the circulation of nude photos of another person without ... continue reading
Pro-life members of Congress this week sent U.S. President Donald Trump two companion letters requesting that he veto any legislation that ... continue reading
The marchers come by the hundreds of thousands to Washington, DC this Friday. Fr. Frank Pavone, National Director, Priests for Life - ... continue reading
Religious freeom is innate and must be protected, US president Donald Trump said in his proclamation for Religious Freedom Day, which is ... continue reading
Cardinal Donald Wuerl will not celebrate the Jan. 18 Mass for Life, to be held at a youth rally before the annual March for Life. Wuerl was ... continue reading
by Catholic Online
- Bill to ban revenge porn introduced in Montana
- Daily Reading for Tuesday, January 22nd, 2019 HD Video
- Daily Readings for Sunday, January 20, 2019
- Holy cow: Farm animals receive blessing outside St Peter's Square
- Daily Reading for Monday, January 21st, 2019 HD Video
- St. Fabian: Saint of the Day for Sunday, January 20, 2019
- Guam archdiocese files for bankruptcy following sex abuse lawsuits
- Prayer Requests Live for Friday, January 18th, 2019 HD
- Daily Reading for Sunday, January 20th, 2019 HD
- Prayer Requests Live for Thursday, January 17th, 2019 HD
- Daily Reading for Saturday, January 19th, 2019HD
Learn about Catholic world
Inform - Inspire - Ignite
Catholic Online Saints
Your saints explained
Catholic Online Prayers
Prayers for every need
Catholic Online Bible
Complete bible online
Catholic Online News
Your news Catholic eye
Today's bible reading
Products and services we offer
Catholic Online Shopping
Catholic medals, gifts & books
The California Network
Inspiring streaming service
Learn the Catholic way
Teacher lesson plans & resources
Support Free Education
Tax deductible support Free education