Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

7/2/2013 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (

Parents sued to get daughter on faster waiting list; doctors say many new questions have been raised

The world has been closely following the plight of 10-year-old Sarah Murnaghan, a girl with end stage cystic fibrosis whose parents sued to have her removed from a child's waiting list for a lung transplant in order to receive lungs from an adult donor in a timely fashion. Sarah is now on her second set of lungs, after her initial transplant was rejected. The incident is provoking questions about ethical behavior in the medical community.

Sarah is now taking some breaths on her own, although she continues to breathe mostly with the help of a ventilator.

Sarah is now taking some breaths on her own, although she continues to breathe mostly with the help of a ventilator.


By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Catholic Online (

7/2/2013 (2 years ago)

Published in Health

Keywords: Sarah Murnaghan, lung transplant, ethics

LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - The second lung transplant given to the Pennsylvania girl raises new questions about how to make the best use of a precious resource, ethicists say.

Sarah's case is controversial as her parents sued to get her onto the transplant list for an adult set of lungs. Typically, children are considered only for child-size lungs.

"Sadly, she faces very long odds of surviving. Even with good donor lungs, survival rates are only 50 percent at six years," Arthur Caplan, a physician and head of the division of bioethics at NYU Langone Medical Center in New York City says.

"She apparently got low quality organs to try and keep her alive to 'bridge' her to another transplant," Caplan says.

"Did it make sense to give her a second set of lungs in a pretty close-to-experimental procedure? She surely needed them, but given her medical situation, should she have been on the adult list in the first place?"

A second organ transplant is inherently controversial. "If the goal is to save lives with scarce lungs, should re-transplants ever be done following an initial acute failure of a first set?" Caplan asks. "I would say no, if others could have used organs who had not had a first shot. That is a tough position, but lung transplants are rare, and not yet on a par with kidney or liver transplants."

Sarah is now taking some breaths on her own, although she continues to breathe mostly with the help of a ventilator. Murnaghan posted pictures on Facebook of her daughter smiling wanly. She's due for additional surgery to repair her diaphragm, which was damaged during the operation, her mother says.

"Sarah is doing well, alert, improving inch by inch," Murnaghan posted on her Facebook page this weekend. Sarah's "surgery will bring us closer to successful extubation," in which doctors remove her breathing tube.

A previous attempt to remove Sarah from her breathing tube was unsuccessful. "Ever since the unsuccessful extubation she has struggled with fears that she will suffocate and stop breathing."

It's always difficult to decide how to allocate organs, because it means denying someone a chance at life, Pediatrician G. Kevin Donovan, director of the Edmund D. Pellegrino Center for Clinical Bioethics says.

The best way to make those decisions "is probably not to involve the courts," Donovan says. "The courts will have the same sympathy that we all would, but not the same medical information" as doctors at the bedside.

"It really is a very difficult case," he says. "And difficult cases make good publicity, but bad precedents."


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'

Copywriter 2015 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for October 2015
That human trafficking, the modern form of slavery, may be eradicated.
Evangelization: That with a missionary spirit the Christian communities of Asia may announce the Gospel to those who are still awaiting it.


More Health

America drinks less soda: The soda industry sees an all-time-low in sales Watch

Image of The soda industry is changing.


Around five years ago, the soda industry fought back against Mayor Michael A. Nutter's proposal of imposing soda taxes in Philadelphia. Soda lobbyists back then organized protests and came up with campaign contributions to local politicians, with the assistance of ... continue reading

5 things people need to know about breast cancer Watch

Image of


Breast cancer is the most prevalent kind of disease that has been affecting women from all over the world. The World Health Organization estimated around 508,000 women die of this disease every year.  LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - While some women fall prey ... continue reading

Early detection test can lead to breast cancer diagnoses before cancer appears Watch

Image of Breast Cancer Awareness Month.


A recent study may make it possible to detect breast cancer before the disease develops. Researchers clarified, however, that the study was based on genetic changes from samples taken from healthy breasts and cancerous breasts. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - The ... continue reading

ACLU sues Catholic hospital over refusal to abort children Watch

Image of The ACLU is insisting that Catholic hospitals abort still-living children.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The ACLU is suing Trinity Health Corporation, a Michigan-based Catholic hospital chain, because the organization refuses to perform abortions. The suit is similar to one brought by the ACLU in 2013, that case was dismissed by a Federal court. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic ... continue reading

Baby born with rare medical mystery thrives Watch

Image of Baby Angelito was born with two tubes for a nose.


Baby Angelito was born with two tubes in place of a nose but his doctors are optimistic about his condition.  LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Daily Mail reported the medical mystery as well as Angelito's doctors' belief the infant will soon appear normal.The ... continue reading

20-million-year old flea carrying bubonic plague may be real reason dinosaurs went extinct Watch

Image of The Black Death plague devastated entire populations (Interfoto/Alamy)


Preserved in amber, a 20-million-year-old flea is believed to contain an ancient form of one of the world's deadliest bacteria: Black Death.  LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA (Catholic Online) - According to the Journal of Medical Entomology, the fossilized bacteria is ... continue reading

Baby born missing majority of skull miraculously beats the odds, reaches first birthday Watch

Image of


Doctors said that Jaxon Buell only had a few days to live after his birth. The boy was born with a rare condition called the Microhydranencephaly, which left the majority of his skull unable to form. Despite the odds, Jaxon is strong and recently celebrated a milestone ... continue reading

New dangerous cluster of Legionnaires' disease reported in the Bronx Watch

Image of Legionnaires' disease is a lung bacteria that causes flue-like muscle pain, headaches, fevers, drowsiness, chills and in some cases delirium.

By Kenya Sinclair (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

A new cluster of Legionnaires' disease has been reported in the Bronx and is not related to the cluster outbreak in the Bronx earlier this summer that left 12 dead. NEW YORK CITY, NY (Catholic Online) - Fox5ny reported seven cases of Legionnaires' disease in the ... continue reading

Why fidgeting may actually be good for your health Watch

Image of


When you feel like fidgeting, don't worry about whether it's bad for you or not. New research shows that being restless and fidgeting at work can actually be good for your health. HOLLYWOOD, CA  (Catholic Online) - A series of studies showed that long periods of ... continue reading

What you need to know about the developmental process of Influenza Watch

Image of Inflammation associated with infection in the soft palate stimulates the sneezing and coughing. This propels the flu virus out of the mouth enabling it to spread easily.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Influenza, or "Flu," the respiratory ailment that hits hardest during the colder months, first develops on the roof of the mouth. That's the findings of researchers, who note that flu is then spread through coughs and sneezes. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) ... continue reading

All Health News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Jonah 4:1-11
1 This made Jonah very indignant; he fell into a ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 86:3-4, 5-6, 9-10
3 take pity on me, Lord, for to you I cry all the ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 11:1-4
1 Now it happened that he was in a certain place ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for October 7th, 2015 Image

St. Artaldus
October 7: Artaldus (also called Arthaud) was born in the castle of ... Read More