Guest Opinion: Peg Luksik Asks, Do What is Legal or What is Right?

The sad thing is that although there is outrage over the results of abandoning what is right for what is legal, the conversation is revolving around changing what is legal

While making laws better is always a good choice, the reality is that no society can make enough laws to cover every eventuality for a society that has made "legal" its highest authority.The most enduring legal code ever written fit on two stone tablets.  That is because its tenets focused on right and wrong 

P>HARRISBURG, PA. (Catholic Online) - Last week, the nation watched in shock and disbelief as one of college football's national icons was fired.  Everyone agreed that Coach Paterno had committed no crime, and that he had obeyed all of the requirements of the law.  He was fired because he ONLY did what was legally required, not what was right.

On Sunday, the television program "60 Minutes" included a story about members of Congress who used inside information to make deals in the stock market that were extremely profitable.  In one case, the deal resulted in approximately $100,000 in profit in less than one week. 

If anyone other than a member of Congress had used the same inside information to make the same deals, that person would have been charged with a crime. But since Congress is exempt from those restrictions, the actions of the elected officials were legal.  The news story did not refute that fact, but the report still called the activity "soft corruption", because JUST being legal doesn't make something right.

This week, Senator Coburn of Oklahoma has released a report on how people with city addresses are collecting farm subsidies, how millionaires are qualifying for energy assistance and collecting unemployment, and how billions of dollars are written off in taxes each year as "gambling losses".  The report states that every single one of the items it addresses is legal, but being legal DOESN'T make the action right.

If we think about it, we would have to admit that everything the British government under King George did was legal.  It just wasn't right. 

This nation was founded on the premise that "right" was more important than "legal".

Yet in one week, we have three high-profile examples of how that standard has changed.  And of how harmful that change in standard can be.

It's easy to point fingers at the high-profile cases, but they do not exist in a vacuum.  They came to exist in a culture that has gradually moved its standard for conduct from right to legal. 

The Penn State tragedy didn't begin a week ago, it has been an ongoing situation during which many people used legal options to avoid the discomfort that would have come with doing the right thing and stopping the abuse.

The Congressional insider trading didn't begin with the "60 Minutes" story, it has been a deepening corruption in government in which elected officials rationalize their own conduct and their constituents turn a blind eye to bad behavior as long as the "pork" continues to arrive.

The examples in the Coburn report didn't begin six months ago, they are long-term practices born out of the mindset that says, "I am going to get my piece of the pie", no matter what my circumstances actually are. 

The sad thing is that although there is outrage over the results of abandoning what is right for what is legal, the conversation is revolving around changing what is legal.  And while making laws better is always a good choice, the reality is that no society can make enough laws to cover every eventuality for a society that has made "legal" its highest authority.

The most enduring legal code ever written fit on two stone tablets.  That is because its tenets focused on right and wrong.  And that legal code is the one that some in America are working to remove from the public marketplace.

If we truly want to avoid a repetition of this past week, perhaps our first step should be to put that code back.

-----

Peg Luksik is the Chairman of the Center for American Heritage. Learn more about the heritage of this exceptional nation at www.centerforamericanheritage.com

---

'Help Give every Student and Teacher FREE resources for a world-class Moral Catholic Education'

Copyright 2021 - Distributed by Catholic Online