Skip to content

Forced abortion decision overturned on appeal, according to reports

Free World Class Education
FREE Catholic Classes

By (CNA/EWTN)
6/24/2019 (4 months ago)
Catholic Online (https://www.catholic.org)

A controversial UK court decision to force a disabled woman to have an abortion has been overturned on appeal.

Highlights

By (CNA/EWTN)
Catholic Online (https://www.catholic.org)
6/24/2019 (4 months ago)

Published in Europe

Keywords: Forced abortion, appeal, reports


London, England, (CNA) - In a decision reportedly reached June 24, the English Court of Appeal, consisting of Lord Justice McCombe, Lady Justice King and Lord Justice Peter Jackson, overturned the previous ruling of the Court of Protection.

According to Press Association reports, the judges said they would issue a full explanation of their decision at a later date, but that the circumstances of the case were "unique."

A spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Clare McCarthy, welcomed the decision in a statement released Monday.

"This is a very welcome decision that will save the life of the unborn child and the mother from a forced late-term abortion and much undue distress. However, the horrific original ruling should never have happened."

"Unfortunately, we fear that this is not a one-off case," McCarthy said.

"We are calling on the Department of Health to urgently reveal how many women have been forced to have an abortion in the UK over the last 10 years and make it clear how they will ensure it will not happen again."

Mrs Justice Nathalie Lieven imposed the original decision on June 21 in the Court of Protection in England, which hears cases involving the legal and personal affairs of people judged to have diminished mental capacity.  

Lieven ruled that a forced abortion was "in the best interests" of the pregnant woman, over the objections of the woman herself, her mother, and her social worker. The woman, who has not been identified, is reportedly in her 20s and is of Nigerian descent. Both she and her mother are Catholic, and the court heard that they objected strongly to the abortion on religious grounds.

The decision on appeal comes after thousands of people signed a petition urging U.K. Health and Social Care Secretary Matthew Hancock to intervene in the case.

Two Catholic bishops in the U.K. had also spoken out against the decision.

The online petition, started by Right to Life UK June 22, has received over 75,000 signatures since it was posted.

The petion urges the Health Secretary "to intervene in this case, so far as possible, to prevent this gross injustice being inflicted by the State on this family and ensure this woman is not forced to have an abortion."

Despite the petition, pro-life Members of Parliament aknowledged there was little chance of a ministerial intervention.

Jacob Rees-Mogg, MP for North-East Somerset, told CNA that "This is deeply troubling but there is no Parliamentary route to challenging this decision."

Doctors who cared for the woman argued that due to her mental capacities, either natural labor or cesarean section delivery could damage her mental health. Her mother, described as a former midwife, along with a social worker who helps care for the woman, both disagree and do not wish to terminate the pregnancy.

The petition also drew attention Lieven's "past advocacy for [the] abortion provider BPAS and her claim that Northern Irelandďż˝ s abortion law is akin to torture."

In Northern Ireland, abortion is only permitted in instances when the mental or physical health of the mother is at risk. BPAS, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, is the largest abortion provider in Britain.

Lieven has said that she is "acutely conscious" that ordering an abortion for a woman who did not want one was an "intense intrusion" by the state.

"I have to operate in [her] best interests, not on society's views of termination," Lieven explained in her decision. Lieven also suggested it would be more traumatic if the woman were to lose custody of her child, who would be a "real baby" after birth.

The woman's mother offered to care for her grandchild, but Lieven dismissed this idea as impractical due to the pregnant woman's mood disorder and developmental delays.

Two Catholic bishops from the United Kingdom also spoke out against the decision.

"Forcing a woman to have an abortion against her will, and that of her close family, infringes upon her human rights, not to mention the right of her unborn child to life in a family that has committed to caring for the child," said Bishop John Sherrington, an auxilary bishop of the Archdiocese of Westminster.

Sherrington serves as the designated spokesman on life issues for the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales.

"In a free society like ours there is a delicate balance between the rights of the individual and the powers of the state," he added. "This is a sad and distressing decision for the whole family whom we keep in our prayers. This case, for which all information is not available, raises serious questions about the meaning of 'best interests' when a patient lacks mental capacity and is subject to the court's decision against her will."

Officials at the Archdiocese of Westminster told CNA that Cardinal Vincent Nichols would not be making a statement of his own.

Bishop John Keenan of the Diocese of Paisley, in Scotland, urged people to sign the petition in a video posted to Twitter by March4LifeUK. Keenan said that the decision "introduces a dangerous new development in the overreach of the power of the state over its citizens," and "has to be changed."

The decision is troubling, Keenan said, "not just in the interests of this woman and her child, but in the interests of everyone who believes in choice in this country, in the interests of everyone who believes in the prerogatives and the rights of citizens over the state."

Scotland has both a separate court system from England and Wales, and the Catholic hierarchy of Scotland has its own bishops' conference.

Police are investigating the circumstances of how the woman became pregnant.

This story is developing and has been updated.


Comments


More Europe

Vatican's London luxury development company, with ties to alleged financial crime, offered to raze parish rectory Watch

Image of London

Developers acting for the Vatican Secretariat of State offered to raze a London parish hall and rectory and replace it with low-cost ... continue reading


Pastor of vibrant Arkansas parish named Bishop of Shreveport Watch

Image of

Pope Francis Tuesday appointed Msgr. Francis Malone, pastor of an Arkansa parish known for having generated many priestly vocations, as the ... continue reading



Pope Francis: The poor, unborn, and elderly are neglected in the frenzy of modern life Watch

Image of Holy Mass with Pope Francis for World Day of the Poor

On the World Day of the Poor, Pope Francis said that the poor and most vulnerable can be left behind in the frenetic haste and ... continue reading


Vatican delegation in Iran discuss human rights with Muslim leaders Watch

Image of

A Vatican delegation traveled to Tehran this week to discuss opportunities for Catholics and Muslims to serve humanity together. Vatican ... continue reading


Pope Francis denounces rise in anti-Semitism Watch

Image of Pope Francis

Pope Francis denounced rising anti-Semitism Wednesday as an attitude that is inhumane and unchristian. Vatican City, (CNA) - Pope Francis ... continue reading


Never Miss any Updates!

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers.

Deacon Keith Fournier Hi readers, it seems you use Catholic Online a lot; that's great! It's a little awkward to ask, but we need your help. If you have already donated, we sincerely thank you. We're not salespeople, but we depend on donations averaging $14.76 and fewer than 1% of readers give. If you donate just $5.00, the price of your coffee, Catholic Online School could keep thriving. Thank you. Help Now >

Catholic Online Logo

Copyright 2019 Catholic Online. All materials contained on this site, whether written, audible or visual are the exclusive property of Catholic Online and are protected under U.S. and International copyright laws, © Copyright 2019 Catholic Online. Any unauthorized use, without prior written consent of Catholic Online is strictly forbidden and prohibited.

Catholic Online is a Project of Your Catholic Voice Foundation, a Not-for-Profit Corporation. Your Catholic Voice Foundation has been granted a recognition of tax exemption under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Federal Tax Identification Number: 81-0596847. Your gift is tax-deductible as allowed by law.