Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Keith A Fournier

3/27/2013 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (

The Government of the State of California has decided it is more enlightened on this matter than its own citizens

At 10:07 AM (EST) on Tuesday morning, March 26, 2013, the oral arguments in Hollingsworth v Perry were held before the United States Supreme Court. Dennis Hollingsworth and others are supporters of Proposition Eight, a constitutional amendment which defended marriage as between one man and one woman.  It was passed by the majority of the voters of California. Though normally the State of California would have defended Proposition Eight because it was lawfully passed by a majority of Californians, it refused to do so because it did not like the results.

Outside of the US Supreme Court

Outside of the US Supreme Court


By Keith A Fournier

Catholic Online (

3/27/2013 (2 years ago)

Published in U.S.

Keywords: marriage, proposition Eight, anti-marriage, gay marriage, DOMA, Defense of Marriage, Hollingsworth v Perry, Keith A Fournier

WASHINGTON, DC (Catholic Online) - At 10:07 AM (EST) on Tuesday morning, March 26, 2013, the oral arguments in Hollingsworth v Perry were held before the United States Supreme Court. Dennis Hollingsworth and others are supporters of Proposition Eight, a constitutional amendment which defended marriage as between one man and one woman.  It was passed by the majority of the voters of California.

The petitioners asked the US Supreme Court to review a decision by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision which upheld the unilateral action of a lower federal Court which struck down the constitutional amendment on its own authority, even though it had been lawfully passed by the citizens of California.

Though normally the State of California would have defended Proposition Eight because it was lawfully passed by a majority of Californians, it refused to do so because it did not like the results. The Government of the State of California decided it was more enlightened on this matter than its own citizens. 

So, Attorney Charles Cooper represented those who asked the Court to uphold Proposition 8. In effect, they asked the Court to uphold marriage for what it is, a union between one man and one woman.

Theodore Olsen represented the Respondents, Kristen M Perry and others. They are homosexual and lesbian partners who seek to use this case to change the definition of marriage by judicial fiat. 

The Obama administration entered the case as well, submitting a "friend of the Court" (Amicus) brief which opposed the will of the people of California and asks the Court to enter into the effort to change the definition of marriage by judicial fiat.

The respondents and the federal government argued that Proposition Eight discriminates against homosexual and lesbian couples. They claimed that it fails to recognize some civil right for homosexuals and lesbians to marry.

The Obama administration argued that Proposition Eight is an unconstitutional violation of the 14th amendment to the United States Constitution because it failed to give equal protection to those homosexual and lesbian couples who insist that they have this civil right to marry.

All day Tuesday the media was filled with people seeking to read the tea leaves, parse the comments of the Judges and make their own predictions of the outcome. The opinion is not expected until June. I know it is a futile task. I am a lawyer who spent much of my career in constitutional work. I had the privilege of serving as co-counsel on several cases at the United States Supreme Court.  I was not in the Court for this argument.

However, a talented lawyer who has made numerous successful appearances before the Court - in whom I place a very high degree of confidence - thinks the Court will effectively bypass the matter by holding that the petitioners had no legal standing before the Court. In other words, they had no ground to even present the case under the law. The reason - they were simply citizens affected by the Appellate Courts refusal to implement their will as reflected in Proposition 8 - not the State of California which should have brought the case in the first instance.

Remember, the State refused to act because they did not agree with the results of the vote. Of course, that raises the question, "Why did the Court even agree to take the case?". The quick answer to support the possibility offered by my source is that the standard for reviewing cases which they will even agree to hear is different than the full review at the hearing. Whether they will find the petitioners had no legal standing and basically return the matter to the prior status - or not - only time will tell. It will be early June before we all know. 

The effect would be to reinstate the opinion of the Ninth Circuit which struck down proposition Eight.  In other words, California would call homosexual and lesbian partnerships - "marriages" -  and grant homosexual and lesbian couples marriage licenses, in spite of what the majority of voters decided. It would have no affect on other States and would leave the entire matter where it was before the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case.

On Wednesday, March 27, 2013, the second marriage case will be heard before the Supreme Court, US v Windsor. The Windsor case involves two women in a lesbian partnership for forty four years. They civilly married in 2007 because Canada granted legal equivalency between homosexual or lesbian partnerships and authentic marriage.

One of the women died and the Federal Government of the United States would not recognize the surviving partner as a spouse for purposes of calculating estate taxes. That is because of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which protects marriage as what it is, between one man and one woman.

Although it is the Federal law, DOMA has been unilaterally rejected by the Justice Department of the United States under the Obama administration. They refuse to enforce it. It has also been assaulted in the Courts by homosexual equivalency activists. On Wednesday, March 27, 2013, the US Supreme Court will weigh in.


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'

Copywriter 2015 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for October 2015
That human trafficking, the modern form of slavery, may be eradicated.
Evangelization: That with a missionary spirit the Christian communities of Asia may announce the Gospel to those who are still awaiting it.


More U.S.

MIRACLES DO HAPPEN: Days-old baby girl buried alive pulled to safety in California Watch

Image of Following the child's muffled cries, police eventually found the girl in a crevice along the biking path. Wrapped in a blanket, covered with a layer of rocks and rubble, the girl was cold - but alive.


While much still needs to be learned - authorities here in Compton, California are gratified to learn that miracles still happen. A days-old baby girl, estimated to be only two to three days old, has been pulled to safety from a riverbed after a passerby heard ... continue reading

Who Needs Advent? I do! Watch

Image of The candle is a symbol of Advent because it is a symbol of Jesus Christ, the Light of the world, who is always coming to those with the eyes of living faith.

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Jesus Christ is not just a memory to the Christian with living faith. He is alive in our midst and living His Life in and through His Body, the Church, of which we are members. The redemptive mission of the Lord Jesus continues until He returns. As Christians, we ... continue reading

BIGGER THAN ISIS - There's a hidden power behind ISIS and it's so big and so powerful, you won't believe this MASSIVE SHOCKING fact about it! Watch

Image of Obama is the titular head of the world's most nefarious terrorist organization, a title he may have inherited from his predecessor, and that will be passed to his successor.


If you were asked, what is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated in human history, how would you answer? Global warming? Vaccines? The Moon Landing? Entire religions?  (Not that we agree with these). But what would you say? In a moment, we're going to offer an answer ... continue reading

'Black Friday' leaving bruises as shoppers trample each other for best deals Watch

Image of Sales for pricey items such as electronic devices erupt into violence on


Everyone has had their turkey leftovers from the previous day's Thanksgiving Feast - and now it's out the door to the nearest "big box" store in a mad scavenger hunt called "Black Friday," where shoppers trample each other for the best deals then can get just before ... continue reading

President likens Syrian refugees to pilgrims on Mayflower in Thanksgiving address Watch

Image of The president then went on to say that, all Americans must open their neighborhoods, their homes, and hearts to Syrian refugees.


United States President Barack Obama called on Americans to welcome Syrian refugees this Thanksgiving season, who - like the pilgrims that set sail on the Mayflower, were likewise fleeing persecution in their native land. LOS ANGELES, CA (California Network) - ... continue reading

Happy Thanksgiving Day: Give Thanks with a Grateful Heart Watch

Image of Around tables throughout America, children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren gather with mothers and fathers, Grandpas and Grandmas, extended family, neighbors and friends to thank God and one another. And then, we feast; not only on the food, but even more importantly, on the gift of the love which informs all family relationships and true friendships, the real source of lasting joy, the love of the God who gave us life and liberty.

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Happy Thanksgiving Day. May it be a day for love and gratitude. No matter how difficult the challenges we face as a Nation, we have much to be grateful for. As we give thanks, we will find the strength we need to love even more fully. As we practice regularly ... continue reading

New ISIS video taunts United States to 'bring it on' Watch

Image of While the video is pumping up Islamist State, the fact of the matter is is the group is suffering heavy losses on the ground form allied bombardment, especially since Russia began bombing the group


A new video from the Islamic State is highlighting the high number of U.S. soldiers who commit suicide, in effect to tell the world's last remaining superpower to "bring it on." U.S. President Barack Obama has since dismissed ISIS as "a bunch of killers with ... continue reading

Horrific outrage erupts over proposed mosque in Virginia after Paris attacks Watch

Image of The Muslim community in Fredericksburg, Virginia has received support from the local Christian and Jewish clergy.


"Nobody wants your evil cult," declared a man at a zoning meeting in Fredericksburg, Virginia. He was lobbing his invective at several American Muslims there over a proposed mosque to be built there. "Every one of you are terrorists. I don't care what you say. ... continue reading

The revealing truth behind the traditional presidential Thanksgiving turkey pardon Watch

Image of President Ronald Reagan was the first U.S. president to use the word


President Obama will pardon two turkeys - named Tom One and Tom Two - from a turkey farm in Modesto California on Thanksgiving Eve as part of an annual presidential tradition. Obama will make a few jokes with his family and then pardon the turkeys to live out ... continue reading

'Domestic terrorism': 5 People shot during Black Lives Matter protest in Minneapolis Watch

Image of Despite a shooting at a Minneapolis Black Lives Matter protest, the group plans to return to the precinct to continue their protests.


Protesters were standing outside the 4th Precinct in Minneapolis for Black Lives Matter in the case of 24-year-old Jamar Clark when gunshots rang out. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) -Five protesters were shot outside the police station Tuesday afternoon as one ... continue reading

All U.S. News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

the FEED
by Catholic Online

  • CRYBABY KILLER: Islamist State fighter breaks down in tears after ...
  • Daily Readings for Monday, November 30, 2015
  • The Miracle Prayer HD Video
  • GRAPHIC IMAGES: Islamic extremist shown being BLOWN UP while making ...
  • Prayer For Courage HD Video
  • MIRACLES DO HAPPEN: Days-old baby girl buried alive pulled to safety ...
  • St. Andrew: Saint of the Day for Monday, November 30, 2015

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Jeremiah 33:14-16
14 "Look, the days are coming, Yahweh declares, when I shall fulfil the ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 25:4-5, 8-9, 10, 14
4 DIRECT me in your ways, Yahweh, and teach me your paths.5 ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 21:25-28, 34-36
25 'There will be signs in the sun and moon and stars; on earth nations ... Read More

Reading 2, First Thessalonians 3:12--4:2
12 May the Lord increase and enrich your love for each other and for all, ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for November 29th, 2015 Image

St. Saturninus
November 29: St. Saturninus Bishop of Toulouse and Martyr ... Read More