Jesus is the Ego amo te, the "I love you" of God to man. It requires a response from us. By an act of faith and love inspired by grace, an "I love you, too," we can appropriate that divine offer of love. In so doing, we will be able to say, "We love, because He first loved us."
LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - In the seventh volume of his series The Glory of the Lord, the theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar asks an unanswerable question: "Where is a beloved person loved-in himself or in the one who loves him?"
The reason the question is unanswerable is that the answer is not either/or as the question supposes; rather, the question must be phrased in manner to allow a both/and answer. Love is found in both the lover and the beloved, not just in one exclusively. The beloved "is loved in the act of the one who loves him, . . . as the one who is constituted this person through this act."
Love is both an act of the lover, but also something that is constitutive, that is, something that forms a part of, the beloved.
In other words, the fact that the beloved is loved changes both the lover and the beloved, and so the love is found in a sense in both the lover and the beloved. If the beloved loves back, the situation is duplicated, but in reverse.
When someone loves us, he expresses that love by the sincere communication, by word or deed, of an "I love you." In saying or doing this, the lover is going out of his self and offering to give his self to the other, to the beloved.
Von Balthasar calls this act "expropriation." The word "expropriate" comes from Latin "ex" meaning "away from" and "propriare" meaning "to make one's own." It means a movement away from, or the opposite of, taking something as one's own; in other words, a giving up, a yielding, an emptying out of self. A gift, for example, is a self-expropriation of one's property to the recipient of the gift.
This "expropriation," this "I love you," immediately puts the beloved to a test: it requires from the beloved a response. He confronts a crisis of sorts.
We might gather up the various options available to the beloved into three. The beloved can respond hot: "I love you too." He can respond cold: "I do not love you." He can respond with an unconstitutive lukewarm shrug of his shoulders, a non-committal answer, a weak and love-avoiding "thank-you," but not beyond.
To respond with an "I don't love you," or to respond with an "I love you too," are constitutive acts: they change us because they are a response, positive or negative, to the lover's "I love you." Either response requires commitment. A lukewarm shrug of the shoulders is more offensive than a rejection because it renders the "I love you" unimportant, not worth a yeah or a nay.
This is perhaps the explanation behind the Scripture: "I know . . . that you are neither cold nor hot. I wish that you were cold or hot. But because you are lukewarm, and neither hot nor cold, I will vomit you out of my mouth." (Rev. 3:15-16)
Von Balthasar explains that in order to "appropriate" a lover's "expropriated" love, that is, when he a beloved says "I love you, too," either by word or deed, the beloved must also "expropriate" himself.
The word "appropriate" derives from the Latin "ad" and "propriare": a movement or action toward taking something as one's own. It is the opposite of expropriate, and yet also requires a sort of self-expropriation.
To "appropriate" love, to say, "I love you too," one must "expropriate" one's self. That is, in an image suggested by von Balthasar, one must "clear a space within one's self" for this love. We must make room, that is empty ourselves of selfishness, to allow the other in.
Now this is difficult enough to do when what is involved is human love, even when the height of human love-that "love between man and woman," in the words of Pope Benedict XVI's encyclical Deus Caritas est, "which is neither planned nor willed, but somehow imposes itself upon human beings," "where body and soul are inseparably joined and human beings glimpse an apparently irresistible promise of happiness," eros-is involved. (Deus Caritas est, Nos. 2, 3).
But what if the offer of love, the "I love you," is from God? What if God is the one who has done the "expropriation"?
Now, God is love says the Apostle St. John (1 John 4:8), and the act by which "God loves us and definitively draws near to us, his own action, is his Son," says von Balthasar.
Jesus is the Ego amo te, the "I love you" of God to man. Jesus is God's "expropriation" of himself to man.
It is a full "expropriation." Nothing, nothing is held back. Christ Jesus, wrote St. Paul in his epistle to the Philippians, though he was "in the form of God, did not deem equality with God something to be grasped at, but rather he emptied himself (ἐκένωσεν = ekenōsen), taking the form of a slave, being made in the likeness of men," and thus he "humbled himself by becoming obedient unto death, even death on the Cross." (Phil. 2:6-8).
This act of the emptying-himself-out of the Son of God, which in Greek verbal form is ekenōsen, is known in theology with the noun kenosis. In Jesus, the kenosis was a plenary "expropriation."
(In von Balthasar's theology, this kenosis of the God-Man is an image of the internal expropriation/appropriation which occurs in the Blessed Trinity, what he calls Ur-kenosis, but that is taking us to another topic.)
This love-offer of God and our response to it finds an analogy in human eros, because this love-offer of God in Christ to man really might be called what Pope Benedict XVI called it, "God's eros," which is of another order altogether, and so is "totally agape." (Deus Caritas est, No. 10)
The response to the love-offer of God in Christ is faith. Faith, writes von Balthasar, is how man's "willingness to undergo his share in the expropriation which will bring him into the sphere of expropriated love" offered to him by God in Christ.
By faith, we say "yes" to God, we expropriate ourselves (or, more precisely, we are given the grace to do so), we yield, give up, make room for the lover, and thereby make it possible to appropriate that love.
This faith is a supernatural gift, itself something appropriated through the self-expropriation of the intellect, which is itself a gift: "I believe, help Thou my unbelief." (Matt. 9:24)
Similarly, we might say with respect to agape love (caritas): it is appropriated through the self-expropriation of the will, which is itself a gift. "I love, help Thou my unlove."
The "I love you" does not end with an "I love you, too." No. Love is not is not a game of Marco Polo, with discrete, playful calls of "I love you" and "I love you, too."
When the beloved responds "I love you, too" to the lover, the lover becomes the beloved of the former beloved, and the beloved now becomes the lover. And so there is a sort of a reversal of roles and a reversal of expropriation and appropriation.
And it does not end there either.
For love is a dynamic thing, a living thing, a sort of dance, a passepied, where the lovers dance a step, elicit a response, which elicits a reply, which elicits a surresponse, which elicits a surreply . . . till death do us part or, if God is involved, in saceula saeculorum, world without end, Amen.
In the inner life of God the Blessed Trinity, we refer to this eternal reciprocal love between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, by the Greek word perichoresis, or by the Latin word circumincessio. By grace, and by grace alone, if we, through self-expropriation, appropriate ourselves of God's expropriation of himself in Christ, by an act of faith and an act of love, we are captured into this eternal round of love.
In us, the dynamic result of Christ's expropriation of himself, our self-expropriation (by grace) so as to appropriate that love, and Christ's appropriation of that love by further expropriation and so on leads to a closer integration, a closer communion, between Jesus the Lord and the Christian soul. It gets to the point, when sanctity is reached, that there is a virtual union as we become constituted in Christ. We virtually become, by grace, other Christs.
That is why St. Paul can say, "I no longer live, but Christ lives in me." (Gal. 2:20) Yet that is also why St. Paul can say, that his life "hidden in Christ in God." (Col. 3:3) St. Paul is fully expropriated and so he fully appropriates Christ. Christ is fully expropriated and has appropriated St. Paul. Christ is in St. Paul, and St. Paul is in Christ.
This, of course, is exactly why Jesus came into the world, and what he prayed for in his high priestly prayer, and what he wants for every single human being on this earth. "I pray, that they may all be one, just as you and I are one, as you are in me, Father, and I am in you." (John 17:21)
So to the impossible-to-answer question, "Where am I loved by God-in myself or in God?" we must answer: It is neither/or, but rather both/and. We are loved by God in ourselves and in God.
Let us then turn, to the Ego amo te of God, Jesus, and yield our entire selves to him. Let us respond to this divine "I love you," neither cold nor lukewarm, but hot: "Jesus, I love you, too, and help my unlove of you so that I, by grace, may learn fully to expropriate myself, fully to make room in my heart and soul, in my life, for you."
Then may we say with the Apostle John: "We love, because he first loved us." (1 John 4:19).
Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas. He is married with three children. He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum. You can contact Andrew at firstname.lastname@example.org.
By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)
Catholic Online is conducting a global survey on Ash Wednesday practices. Each reader is asked to participate once. The survey will take less than a minute to complete. The results of the survey will help Catholic Online determine how best to serve your needs in the ... continue reading
By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)
Despite the Catholic Church openly saying Santa Muerte is not recognized as a saint, the death saint continues to spread in popularity among Mexican citizens. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - "Santa Muerte is an absurdity," Cardinal Norberto Rivera, Mexico's ... continue reading
By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)
Televangelist Morris Cerullo has been attempting to build a Bible-themed luxury resort for the past few years - and now there is only one more hurdle to jump. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - After purchasing a foreclosed Mission Valley hotel, Cerullo's plans for ... continue reading
By Joan Frawley Desmond, National Catholic Register
When recent headlines marked a spike in drug overdoses for white, middle-class Americans, the news saddened but did not surprise Deacon Timothy Flanigan, an HIV specialist at Brown University medical school in Providence, R.I. Providence, R.I. (National ... continue reading
By CNA/EWTN News
Priests who are good confessors must recognize their own sins in order to forgive and comfort penitents, Pope Francis said one day before the start of the Lenten season. Vatican City (CNA/EWTN News) - "I speak to you as a brother, and through you I would like to ... continue reading
By Pope Francis, Libreria Editrice Vaticana
Dear brothers and sisters, good morning and good path of Lent!It is beautiful and also significant to have this hearing at this Ash Wednesday. We begin the journey of Lent, and we are reflecting today on the ancient institution of the "jubilee"; It is an ancient thing, ... continue reading
By Pope Franics, Vatican Radio
"I desire mercy, and not sacrifice" (Mt 9:13).The works of mercy on the road of the Jubilee 1. Mary, the image of a Church which evangelizes because she is evangelizedIn the Bull of Indiction of the Extraordinary Jubilee of Mercy, I asked that "the season of Lent in ... continue reading
By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)
The cost of living in San Francisco has skyrocketed to the point that and new reports indicate Bay Area housing has reached such heights that the area's average income can no longer support it. Unfortunately, this means everyone is downsizing or moving - including ... continue reading
By Ann Schneible, CNA/EWTN News
The plight of Syrian civilians involved in the nation's ongoing conflict was at the heart of Pope Francis' appeal to the international community on Sunday, in an address where he also called for a renewed commitment to the protection of life at all stages. ... continue reading
By Pope Francis
Dear brothers and sisters, Goodmorning!The Gospel of this Sunday says - in the drafting of St. Luke - the call of the first disciples of Jesus ( Lk 5,1-11). The fact takes place in a context of everyday life: there are some fishermen on the shore of Lake Galilee, who, ... continue reading