Skip to content

What He Actually Said! Excerpts from Wide Ranging Interview With Pope Francis on Return Trip from the Holy Land

By Deacon Keith Fournier
5/30/2014 (3 years ago)
Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

Given the flurry of speculation, parsing and propaganda pretending to be journalism already flooding the integrated media, I wanted to get the actual remarks out as soon as possible.

Rather then enter into the misguided mix of what purports to be journalism surrounding this Pope, I choose instead to offer to our readers the first English translation of many of the excerpts of this truly fascinating, informative, frank and faithful interview. I ask our readers to actually READ what the Pope said! Pray about his responses. Pray for him. Pray for the Church. Be a good Christian - and do not join the ranks of the propagandized lemmings, repeating the opinion of this purported journalist or that purported journalist. We are living in an historic moment in Church history! Francis is a prophetic and pastoral Pope who has already made his mark on that history - and appears to just be warming up. He is a man with a deep relationship with the Lord Jesus; a man of constant prayer. He is an evangelical Catholic Pope, filled with the hope and joy which comes from the Gospel. 

(Pictured: Pope Francis on the plane) - We have an obligation to become men and women of prayer, grounded in the Bible and actual teachings of the magisterium of the Catholic Church. We need to be ready to defend the Church. We also have a special obligation to work with our other Christian friends as they try to sort though what this Pope is actually saying, in the morass of often propagandized media reports.

(Pictured: Pope Francis on the plane) - We have an obligation to become men and women of prayer, grounded in the Bible and actual teachings of the magisterium of the Catholic Church. We need to be ready to defend the Church. We also have a special obligation to work with our other Christian friends as they try to sort though what this Pope is actually saying, in the morass of often propagandized media reports.

TEL AVIV, Israel (Catholic Online) - The media will spend Tuesday, May 27, 2014, and probably  the entire last week of May, speculating about the hour long, wide ranging, spontaneous interview given by Pope Francis to the journalists who accompanied him upon his return from his historic visit to the Holy Land.

For any observers who had thought that the wide ranging, spontaneous style of Francis with the Media would soon end, they were simply wrong. This is a warm-hearted, pastoral, confident in his faith and office, Pope - and he is on a mission for the Lord He serves.

His remarks, completely spontaneous, will be picked apart, placed under the media version of a microscope (or even a kaleidoscope), then reinterpreted through the prism of political ideologies and theological speculation.

They will also be recast in accordance with various agendas, both political and theological. They will be used to advance the narrative of people who often do not care about what was actually said.

Then, they will be used to speculate about the future of the Catholic Church - as if these answers were some new kind of ecclesiastical tea leaves. They are not. They are the heartfelt responses of a genuine, spirit filled Christian Leader who actually is transparent - and does not just use the word.

Rather then enter into the misguided mix of what purports to be journalism surrounding this Pope, I choose to offer to our readers some excerpts from the first English translation of this truly fascinating, informative, frank and faithful interview.

I ask our readers to actually READ what Pope Francis said!

Then - Pray about his responses. Pray for him. Pray for the Catholic Church. Pray for all Christians. Be a good Christian and do not join the ranks of the propagandized lemmings, simply repeating the opinion of this purported journalist or that purported journalist. We are living in an historic moment in Church history!

These may be challenging times, but they are our times. We were born - and born again - for these times!

Catholic Christians need to move beyond allowing themselves to be pulled along by the currents of the age. We must stop assuming that what we read on the front page of our newspapers, or on this or that internet news "source" is actually accurate!

We have an obligation to become men and women of prayer, grounded in the Bible and actual teachings of the magisterium (the teaching office) of the Catholic Church. We need to be ready to defend the Church. We also have a special obligation to work with our other Christian friends as they try to sort though what this Pope is actually saying, in the morass of often propagandized media reports.

Francis is a prophetic and pastoral Pope who has already made his mark on history - and appears to just be warming up. He is a man with a deep relationship with the Risen Lord Jesus; and a man of constant prayer. He is an evangelical Catholic Pope, filled with the hope and joy which comes from the knowing the One revealed in the Gospel. 

The following excerpts are taken from one of the many English translations which are now being circulated in the European media. I am sure a more accurate translation will be offered by the official Vatican sources.

However, given the flurry of speculation, parsing and propaganda pretending to be journalism already flooding the integrated media, I wanted to get the actual remarks out as soon as possible.

The translation of these remarks were offered by the very competent and reliable journalist Andrea Torniella, writing for La Stampa, the Vatican Insider. The questions preceding them are not the translation of the actual questions asked on the plane but a summary of the topic which was apparently raised by a journalist in the context of such questions.

*****
 
1) When asked about the abuse of minors by Catholic clerics:

"At the moment there are three bishops under investigation. One has already been convicted and the punishment needs to be decided. There will be no preferential treatment when it comes to child abuse. In Argentina we call those who receive preferential treatment "spoiled children". There will be no "spoiled children" in this case. It is a very serious problem.

When a priest commits abuse, he betrays the Lord's body. A priest must guide children towards sainthood. And the child trusts him. But instead, he abuses him or her. This is very serious. It's like celebrating a black mass!

Instead of steering him or her towards the sainthood you create a problem that will stay with him or her for all of his or her life. Next week, from 6 to 7 June, there will be a mass with some abuse victims in St. Martha's House. Then I will hold a meeting with them. A zero tolerance approach needs to to be adopted with regards to this issue."

2) When asked about allegations of financial impropriety, IOR reform and the Vatican bank 

"The Lord Jesus once told his disciples: scandals are inevitable, we are humans and all of us are sinners. The issue is preventing more from happening. Economic administration requires honesty and transparency.

The two commissions, the one which investigated the IOR and the one which looked into the financial and economic situation of the Vatican as a whole, have now reached their conclusions and will carry forward the recommended reforms, along with the ministry and Secretariat for the Economy headed by cardinal Pell.

But there will still be incongruities, there always will be because we are humans. And the reform process needs to be ongoing. The Church's fathers said the Church must be "simper reformanda". We are sinners, we are weak. The Secretariat for the Economy will help prevent scandals and problems.

For example, 1600 illegitimate accounts have been closed down in the IOR. The IOR is there to help the Church, bishops, dioceses, Vatican staff, their widows and embassies have the right to an account with the IOR, but no one else. It is not an open thing.

And this was work well done, closing down the accounts of those who were not entitled to have one. I would like to say one thing: the question regarding the 15 million Euros is still being looked into; it is not yet clear what happened."

3) When asked about his invitation to Rome, to pray for peace, which he spontaneously issued to both the Israeli and Palestinian Leader

"The most genuine gestures are those which are made spontaneously. I had thought something could be done but none of the concrete gestures I made was conceived that way.

Some things, like the invitation to the two presidents we had thought of doing there, during the visit, but there were lots of logistical problems, many, the place where we intended for it to happen was not an easy one.

But in the end, the invitation was accepted and I hope the meeting will go well.

But my gestures were not pre-planned, I just do what comes to me spontaneously. Just to clarify about the meeting in the Vatican. The purpose of the meeting will be to pray not meditate.

The two presidents and I will only meet to pray and I believe that prayer is important and doing this helps. Then they will go home. There will be a rabbi, a Muslim and me. I have asked the Custody of the Holy land to deal with the practical side of things."

4) When asked about the possible meaning of recent European elections and the shortcomings of the global economic system:   

"I only had time to pray the Our Father a few times but I have had no news regarding the elections.

Populism in Europe, trust and mistrust, some theories about the Euro ... I don't know much about this kind of thing. But unemployment is serious: we have a global economic system that is centred on money, nit a human person. In order to keep going, this system discards things.

It discards children: birth rates are not high, in Italy the average couple has less than two children and in Spain even less. It discards the elderly, even though euthanasia in disguise, medicine is only administered up until a certain point. And young people  are discarded too. 

I think unemployment among Italy's young is 40%, in Spain it's 50%, in Andalucia, 60%. There is an entire generation of people that is not studying or working. This culture of waste is very serious. Europe is not the only place where tit exists,  but it is strongly felt in Europe.

It is an inhumane economic system. Like I said in Evangelii Gaudium, this economic system kills."

5) When asked about the political controversies over Jerusalem: 

"There are many proposals regarding the Jerusalem issue, the Catholic Church and the Vatican's position is based on a religious point of view: a city of peace for the three religions. Concrete measures for peace must be negotiated, it may be decided that this part will become the capital of one state and the other part, of the other state ...

But I don't feel it is my place to say that this or that must be done, it would be foolish on my part, I think we need to go into this in a spirit of fraternity and mutual trust, following the path of negotiation. Courage is needed and I pray to the Lord that these two presidents have the courage to go on. About Jerusalem, all I will say is that it should be the city of peace of the three religions."

6) When asked about the possibility of admitting married men to the candidacy for priesthood in the Latin Rite:

"The Catholic Church has married priests in the Eastern rites. Celibacy is not a dogma of faith, it is a rule of life that I appreciate a great deal and I believe it is a gift for the Church.

The door is always open given that it is not a dogma of faith."

7) When asked about his conversation with orthodox Patriarch Bartholomew and efforts toward full communion with the Orthodox Church:

"With Bartholomew we talked about unity, that comes along the path, during a journey, we could never create unity at a theological congress. He confirmed to me that Athenagoras did tell Paul VI; "Let's put all theologians on an island and we'll go on together."

We need to help one another, in terms of churches for example, even in Rome many Orthodox faithful use Catholic Churches. We spoke about the pan-Orthodox council so that something can be done about the date for Easter. It is a bit ridiculous: tell me, when does your Christ rise from the dead?

Mine will next week. Well, mine was resurrected last week.

Bartholomew and I speak as brothers, we love each other and we talk about the difficulties we face as leaders. We spoke a great deal about ecology and coming up with a joint initiative to deal with this problem."

8) When asked about upcoming Asian trips and his concern about Religious Freedom as a fundamental human right

"There are two Asian trips planned: one to South Korea and then next January, a two-day trip to Sri Lanka and the Philippines, to the area affected by the tsunami. The problem of the lack of freedom in the practice of religion is not only limited to some Asian countries but extends to others too.

Religious freedom is something not all countries have. Some control to some extent, others take measures that end up being full on persecution. There are martyrs today, Christian, catholic and non-Catholic martyrs. In some place you are forbidden from wearing a cross, possessing a bible or teaching children catechism. I think there are more martyrs now that the early Church had seen.

We need to approach certain places carefully, to go and help them, pray a lot for these Churches that are suffering, suffering a great deal and even bishops and the Holy See are working with discretion in order to help Christians in these countries, but it's not easy task.

In one country, for example, people are forbidden to pray together. Christians there want to celebrate the Eucharist and there's a man who is an ordinary workman but acts as a priest and he goes there to the table with the others: they pretend they're drinking tea but they are celebrating the Eucharist.

If the police turns up, they hide the books so it just looks as though they are having tea."

9) When asked about the possibility of his own resignation  in the future

"I will do what the Lord tells me to do. Pray and try to follow God's will. Benedict XVI no longer had the strength and honestly, as a man of faith, humble as he is, he took this decision.

Seventy years ago, Popes Emeritus didn't exist.

What will happen with Popes Emeritus? We need to look at Benedict XVI as an institution, he opened a door, that of the Popes Emeritus. The door is open, whether there will be others, only God knows. I believe that if a bishop of Rome feels he is losing his strength, he must ask himself the same questions Pope Benedict XVI did."

10) When asked about the upcoming Synod of Bishops on the family

"The Synod will be on the family, the problem it is facing, its assets and the current situation it is in. The preliminary report presented by Cardinal Kasper contained five chapters, four of which outlined positive points regarding the family and their theological foundation.

The fifth chapter was to do with the pastoral problem of separation and the annulment of marriages and the administration of communion to divorced people who marry a second time, comes into this.

What I didn't like, was what some people, within the Church as well, said about the purpose of the Synod: that it intends to allow remarried divorcees to take communion, as if the entre issue boiled down to a case.

We know that today the family is facing a crisis, a global crisis, young people don't want to marry or they live together. I wouldn't like us to fall into this question: will it be possible for communion to be administered or not? The pastoral problem regarding the family is vast.

Each case needs to be looked at separately.

I would like to return to something Benedict XVI said on three occasions: the procedures for the annulment of marriage must be looked into, the faith with which a person enters marriage must also be examined and we also need to make it clear that the divorced are not excommunicated.

So often they are treated as thought they have been excommunicated. Choosing the theme for the Synod on the Family was a powerful spiritual experience, the discussion turned slowly towards the family. I am sure it was the Spirit of the Lord that guided us to this point." ...

---


'Help give every student and teacher Free resources for a world-class moral Catholic education'


Copyright 2017 - Distributed by THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for OCTOBER 2017
Workers and the Unemployed.
That all workers may receive respect and protection of their rights, and that the unemployed may receive the opportunity to contribute to the common good.


Comments


More Middle East

Vatican concerned over President Trump's decision in Israel Watch

Image of U.S. President, Donald Trump announced he would be moving the U.S. Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem.

Following U.S. President Donald Trump's Dec. 6 notice that he will be moving the U.S. embassy in Israel to Jerusalem, the Holy See has ... continue reading


Pope Francis opposes Trump plan to move embassy to Jerusalem Watch

Image of President Trump has announced the U.S. embassy will move from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.

President Trump is announcing that the U.S. embassy in Tel Aviv, Israel will soon be moved to Jerusalem, which is the actual capital of ... continue reading


Archaeologists discover ancient Christian inscription with a surprising origin Watch

Image of The inscription reveals the presence of Georgian Christians in Israel.

Archaeologists have discovered a beautiful, 1,500-year-old Christian mosaic in Israel. The work of art is dated to 539 A.D. and is ... continue reading


Massive killer quake strikes border between Iraq and Iran, felt as far away as Israel Watch

Image of Several tall buildings collapses and many other were rendered uninhabitable by the quake. About 70,000 people were left without shelter.

A massive quake has killed over 400 people, and injured thousands in the border region between Iraq and Iran. The quake struck around 9:18 ... continue reading


50 years of Israeli occupation - enough is enough! Watch

Image of What is it going to take to reach peace?
[Photo by: tikkun.org]

Fifty years is a long time to endure forced suffering. Since the 1967 Arab-Israeli War when Israel captured and occupied the Palestinian ... continue reading


Never Miss any Updates!

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers.

Information
Learn about Catholic world

Catholic Online
Inform - Inspire - Ignite

Catholic Online Saints
Your saints explained

Catholic Online Prayers
Prayers for every need

Catholic Online Bible
Complete bible online

Catholic Online News
Your news Catholic eye

Daily Reading
Today's bible reading

Lent / Easter
Death & resurrection of Jesus

Advent / Christmas
Birth of Jesus

Rest of Catholic Online
All Catholic world we offer

Services
Products and services we offer

Catholic Online Shopping
Catholic medals, gifts & books

The California Network
Inspiring streaming service

Advertise on Catholic Online
Your ads on catholic.org

Catholic Online Email
Email with Catholic feel

Catholic Online Singles
Safe, secure Catholic dating

The California Studios
World-class post production service

Education
Learn the Catholic way

Catholic Online School
Free Catholic education for all

Student Classes
K-12 & Adult Education Classes

Catholic Online MasterClass
Learn from experts

School Teachers
Teacher lesson plans & resources

Catholic Media Missionaries
The New Evangelization

Support Free Education
Tax deductible support Free education

Socials
Connect with us online

Catholic Online on Facebook
Catholic social network

Catholic Online on Twitter
Catholic Tweets

Catholic Online on YouTube
Enjoy our videos

Catholic Online on Instagram
Shared Catholic moments

Catholic Online on Pinterest
Catholic ideas style inspiration

Catholic Online Logo

Copyright 2017 Catholic Online. All materials contained on this site, whether written, audible or visual are the exclusive property of Catholic Online and are protected under U.S. and International copyright laws, © Copyright 2017 Catholic Online. Any unauthorized use, without prior written consent of Catholic Online is strictly forbidden and prohibited.