Skip to main content


Answering the Call: A Young Man's Journey to the Priesthood

The law of love, the Cross, is the answer to the messiness

Father David Carter brings the idealism and energy of youth to the priesthood; yet, he also has a maturity and wisdom far beyond his thirty-one years. He is a holy priest. He could have been whatever he wanted in this life, enjoyed everything that the secular world has to offer. So why did he give it up and become a priest?

Father David Carter in front of Chartres Cathedral in France

Father David Carter in front of Chartres Cathedral in France

KNOXVILLE, TN (Catholic Online) - My first recollection of Father David Carter was when I heard that he was going into the seminary around thirteen years ago. He was a teenager. Father Carter represents the best of his generation. Unlike so many, he was not beguiled by the shallowness of this age or its false promises. Although he has grown much over the years, he brings the idealism and energy of youth to the priesthood; yet, he also has a maturity and wisdom far beyond his thirty-one years.

Father Carter is a holy priest. He offers the Mass with the utmost reverence. He is accessible and kind. He has the voice of an angel, and he is intelligent. He also has a Bachelors Degree in philosophy and advanced degrees in theology and canon law. He could have been whatever he wanted in this life, enjoyed everything that the secular world has to offer. So why did he give it up and become a priest? I interviewed him because I wanted an answer to that question. I found the answer informative and surprising. The interview is as follows:

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): What kind of environment did you grow up in?

Fr. Carter: I grew up in a conservative environment. I lived in Shreveport, Louisiana until I was eleven-years old. Then we moved to Knoxville, Tennessee. We had a strong sense of family and religion growing up. Other people in my life, such as neighbors and teachers, shared many of our values. They were moral people. As a result, my environment was healthy and stable. I wasn't exposed to a lot of the detrimental thinking and confusion of our time.

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): When you were a child, did you or your parents have any idea that you would become a priest?

Fr. Carter: No. I had a very normal childhood. My desires were like most young people my age. I wanted worldly success. I wanted to get married and have a family. When I was about fourteen, my religion teacher told us that God has a plan for us, that He created us and has a vocation for us. She told us not to be afraid to ask God what He wants us to do with our lives. I took her comments seriously and prayed about it. I thought about flying planes and being an architect. I also thought about public service jobs like being a fireman or a policeman or joining the military.

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): But I presume you were an angelic child?

Fr. Carter: Not really. During religious education classes, I was put out in the hall a couple times for cutting up in class. I even got into huge trouble once. My parents put me into a Catholic school when I was in the fourth grade. I guess because I was the new kid, I became a target of bullies. It got to the point that I could not take it anymore, so I fought back. But the principal caught me going ballistic on the other guy, and I ended up being expelled over the incident.

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): Well, then, did you have some sort of a conversion experience?

Fr. Carter: It was not any one experience. First of all, my parents always took us to Church on Sundays and holy days of obligation. I also remember those times when we prayed as a family. I was an altar server for many years. I was also involved in a youth group and the Boy Scouts. I became an Eagle Scout. Being in these organizations trained and molded me for a life of service. They gave me a strong desire to serve.

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): Did your desire to serve others influence your decision to become a priest?

Fr. Carter: Yes, but there were other experiences that influenced my decision as well. I remained an altar server throughout my high school years. When I was sixteen, I would usually carry the cross. It was heavy. After holding it a while, my muscles would fatigue. But I did not falter because I was doing it for the Lord. My pastor noticed my attitude and my effort, and on one of these occasions, he suggested that I might have a calling to the priesthood. I was flabbergasted. My first thought was no thanks. I was thinking about marriage, family and worldly success. However, I later met with the Associate Pastor. He was a young priest, and he had a strong influence on me. I also remember a sign on his office door encouraging vocations to the priesthood. It said, "For God's sake do something with your life."

Catholic Online (Michael Terheyden): Are there any other experiences you want to mention?

Fr. Carter: My high school civics teacher had us write an essay about where we wanted to be in ten years. The assignment helped me realize that I wanted things like peace, joy, and ...


1 | 2  Next Page

Rate This Article

Very Helpful Somewhat Helpful Not Helpful at All

Yes, I am Interested No, I am not Interested

Rate Article

1 - 10 of 17 Comments

  1. SS
    2 years ago

    Father Carter taught some of our RCIA classes as we were coming into the church in Easter '06 at St. Jude's. A truly inspiring man of God.

  2. MADELEINE
    2 years ago

    TERRIFIC interview--it is very moving and encouraging to read how Father was called to serve the Church!! Without our priests, there is no EUCHARIST, OR HEALING OF RECONCILIATION, OR ANNOINTING OF THE SICK!!

  3. Donna
    2 years ago

    I am sure that his story will help others in discerning the call to the priesthood. I am finding out that our brother converts to the Catholic faith are answering the call to the priesthood. May we have many more vocations to the priesthood. We NEED them as without priests we will not have the Mass.

  4. Zinnia MIlburn
    2 years ago

    Hi Martins Paul!This is a story of a priest who waited for 20 years to become a priest. He escaped the communist regime in Vietnam & became a refugee in Canada.There were many obstacles that he had to encounter & it was a hard life. In spite all these he never give up.He hanged on trusting God and his devotion to the Blessed Mary that one day his prayers will be answered.In May of 2002 he was ordain to the priesthood. My point here is that keep asking until God will get tired listening to you.Just like the persistent widow in the scripture. I will include you in our prayers during our Serra Club Eucharistic Adoration for Vocations that we do here in Toronto, Canada.
    Zinnia Milburn, Toronto Canada

  5. Zinnia Milburn
    2 years ago

    It is indeed a good news!The story like Fr. David is an affirmation of his love to God.As a member of the Serra Club of Toronto Downtown, Canada we have a Vocations program called Eucharistic Adoration for Vocations.It is a devotion that is brought to different parishes in praying for vocations to the priesthood& religious life & for those who are already practicing their vocations.Why? We should never stop praying for holy priest so that they will be faithful in their service to God.They need our prayers.The good news is that our prayers are being answered.Interest to the call for vocations to the priesthood had increased.This I want to share with you the good news!
    Zinnia Milburn

  6. B
    2 years ago

    I am blessed to belong to All Saints Catholic Church in Knoxville. Fr. David truly is a holy and humble priest. His love for the Eucharist is genuine. And he is a most gentle confessor. When my daughter went to the sacrament of penance for the first time, he was the only priest she considered. God bless you, Fr. David. May you do the Lord's work for many more years to come!

  7. JeanCatherine
    2 years ago

    martins paul

    I dont know if your talking to all of us but first of all trust in your Lord and second have you considered talking to a priest or Bishop in your area? Make an appointment with one of them and just talk. Find a good Holy Priest as Mother Angelica would say.

    God Bless will pray for you and your path that the Lord has for you.

  8. JeanCatherine
    2 years ago

    Margarett RBC Zavodny

    I think Father was being broad and yes we all serve etc the Lord in many ways.

    Being a Mother, Father, Sister or Brother in a family is as noble as those who serve in the Priesthood/Religious life as well. Christ said so.

    Im sure Father as I was saying is talking only of the priesthood aspect of it. As stated we all serve as our Lord asks us to.

  9. Michael Terheyden
    2 years ago

    Audrey, rest assured that you have my prayers. You too, Martins Paul; and I hope that you will contact a priest in your vicinity.

  10. gail labar
    2 years ago

    This is a wonderful story of a wonderful young man who at a very young age really had the meaning of being a good public servant. He really put his whole heart and soul into what he wanted to do and become. I know he will contiune to serve the people he has come to know and to the ones he is yet to know. I wish him God's greatest blessings and Godspeed. We need more young men like him in our world.


Leave a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws including copyright. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion.

Though we invite robust discussion, we reserve the right to not publish any comment which denigrates the human person, undermines marriage and the family, or advocates for positions which openly oppose the teaching of the Catholic Church.

This is a supervised forum and the Editors of Catholic Online retain the right to direct it.

We also reserve the right to block any commenter for repeated violations. Your email address is required to post, but it will not be published on the site.

We ask that you NOT post your comment more than once. Catholic Online is growing and our ability to review all comments sometimes results in a delay in their publication.

Send me important information from Catholic Online and it's partners. See Sample

Post Comment

Find your Path Now