Skip to main content

Dignity, not utility, must govern bioethics, says Catholic speaker in Stanford talk

PALO ALTO, CA (Catholic San Francisco) - Human dignity rises above all other considerations in biomedical research and health care and must govern ethical decisions in the lab and at the bedside, Dr. Edmund Pellegrino, the chairman of the President’s Council on Bioethics, told Stanford law students April 9.

Dr. Pellegrino covered the council’s newly published anthology, “Human Dignity and Bioethics.” The book is a response to critics who have complained that dignity is both too vague a standard and too theologically oriented to have a place in bioethics.

Addressing students in a classroom at Stanford Law School, Dr. Pellegrino made a forceful claim for the inescapability of dignity - the lived experience of being human — for anyone making ethical choices in research, in the clinic and in general biology.

“Wherever you start, wherever you go, you’ll have to come back to either accepting the notion or denying it utterly, and then we can weigh out for you the implications of denying that to a human being,” Dr. Pellegrino said.

“There are too many examples in the world’s history of the denigration of the special nature of being human,” he said. “I can only mention the Holocaust. It’s a reality then — a value you must deal with.”

State-funded embryo destruction

Dr. Pellegrino did not address human embryonic stem cell research directly, but his appearance came just four days after an advisory group to the state-funded California Institute for Regenerative Medicine recommended issuing $262 million in Proposition 71 funds for stem-cell research facilities. Stanford is in line to receive $47.5 million, which would be the largest grant among the 12 the panel is proposing.

In January, the institute, the world’s largest funder of human embryonic stem-cell research, criticized President Bush for what it called a misleading assessment of stem cell research in his state of the union address. The institute said human embryonic stem cells are the “gold standard” for research and that safe alternatives for human studies will not be ready in the foreseeable future because of safety concerns.

“Therefore it is critical that all avenues of stem-cell research be aggressively advanced,” the institute said.

The Catholic Church condemns human embryonic stem cell research because the work involves the destruction of days-old embryos to obtain the cells. Surplus embryos from in-vitro fertilization clinics are one source of the embryos used in research. The Church supports other avenues of stem cell research that do not destroy life.

Henry T. Greeley, a Stanford law professor who chairs the California Advisory Committee on Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research, addressed the Stanford class after Dr. Pellegrino. He said he has some sympathy for an ethical theory that goes beyond individual autonomy but argued that proponents of dignity have not made a suitably rigorous case.

“I don’t see why the human species as a whole is inherently entitled to dignity,” he said. “If it turns out we encounter non-human persons, either biological, mechanical or computational, earthly or alien, I think dignity should apply to them as well. Furthermore, the idea that the species as a whole has some essence that shouldn’t be violated strikes me as way too abstract.”

Defining ‘dignity’

A third panelist, David Magnus, an associate professor of pediatrics at Stanford Medical School, said the council’s new book constitutes a rejection of academic bioethics in favor of more attention to religion and efforts to probe deeper questions of human dignity and human nature. He said the book brings out a fundamental tension between those who are theologically inclined and those who are less so.

Magnus wondered whether two types of dignity could be articulated, one arising from human nature and another governing threats to dignity in the lived experience. He cited what he said was the factual example of a gravely ill infant who was being maintained on life support at the request of the family but whose plight was deeply troubling to the caregivers. Nurses and social workers felt the treatment was unethical.

“It was hard to see what they were saying except in the sense that the human dignity of the child was being violated, the sense that even though the patient doesn’t feel pain, the patient’s dignity is being violated. Its spirit is being injured.”

In questions posed to the panelists after the discussion, a student said the principle of autonomy tends to be worked out in a “very thin way.”

“I see human dignity as trying to fill out something we all yearn for,” the student said, addressing Greeley.

In response, Greeley said, “If we’re going to use it we better have a very good idea of what it means. Otherwise I’m reluctant to sign on to it.”

---

This story was made available to Catholic Online by permission of Catholic San Francisco (www.catholic-sf.org),official newspaper of the Archdiocese of San Francisco, Calif.

Keywords:



NEWSLETTERS »

E-mail:       Zip Code: (ex. 90001)
Today's Headlines

Sign up for a roundup of the day's top stories. 5 days / week. See Sample

Rate This Article

Very Helpful Somewhat Helpful Not Helpful at All

Yes, I am Interested No, I am not Interested

Rate Article

0 Comments

Leave a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws including copyright. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion.

Though we invite robust discussion, we reserve the right to not publish any comment which denigrates the human person, undermines marriage and the family, or advocates for positions which openly oppose the teaching of the Catholic Church.

This is a supervised forum and the Editors of Catholic Online retain the right to direct it.

We also reserve the right to block any commenter for repeated violations. Your email address is required to post, but it will not be published on the site.

We ask that you NOT post your comment more than once. Catholic Online is growing and our ability to review all comments sometimes results in a delay in their publication.

Send me important information from Catholic Online and it's partners. See Sample

Post Comment


Newsletter Sign Up

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Ezekiel 37:1-14
The hand of Yahweh was on me; he carried me away by the spirit ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 107:2-3, 4-5, 6-7, 8-9
So let them say whom Yahweh redeemed, whom he redeemed from the ... Read More

Gospel, Matthew 22:34-40
But when the Pharisees heard that he had silenced the Sadducees ... Read More

Saint of the Day

August 22 Saint of the Day

St. Andrew the Scot
August 22: Archdeacon and companion of St. Donatus. Andrew and his sister, ... Read More