Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

7/3/2012 (3 years ago)

Catholic Online (

Civilly and publicly we live life as if God does not exist, a life of practical atheism

We moderns, the German sociologist Max Weber said, have voluntarily placed ourselves in an "iron cage" of secularism, a life where most of our public life is lived, and civil and political discourse is conducted, in purely secular terms.  Civilly and publicly we live life as if God does not exist, a life of practical atheism.  So-called "public reason"--which is the only reason allowed in the "iron cage"--does not allow God-talk, disdains Christianity, and positively despises Catholicism. 


By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

Catholic Online (

7/3/2012 (3 years ago)

Published in Living Faith

Keywords: secularism, faith, reason, modernity, atheism, secular humanism, Andrew Greenwell

CORPUS CHRISTI, TX (Catholic Online) - In a phrase made famous by the cleric Richard Neuhaus, Americans live in a "naked public square."  What Neuhaus meant by this phrase is that through a long sort of perverse development our civil and political lives have become entirely secularized: God and Faith are removed from public civil and political discourse, including academia, public schools, health care, science and technology, the media, politics and law. 

According to this modern way of thinking, God and Faith belong only within the confines of the four walls of the Church.  In the open, ample field that covers everything else, God and Faith (what the liberal political philosopher John Rawls--in secular terms--referred to as a "comprehensive doctrine") is expected to be bracketed, cabined, or perhaps more applicably "churched." 

This, so the story goes, is done to make us more "free," more "equal," and to prevent some people from forcing others to do things against their will.  We may not have a good life, but at least we have the goods life, and freedom is maximized and oppression minimized.

There is some value in seeing the ostracizing of God and Faith from public life as something that results in citizens being "disrobed" or "naked."  Priests wear vestments in the Church, but not outside of it.  Priests do not wear chasubles to political rallies.  And so secularists think that what is required by good liturgy is required by good politics.

There is an ominous aspect to the insistence of a "naked public square."  Obviously, disrobed or naked citizens are much easier to control and manipulate and get to accept the wiles of the devil as good (namely, the entire gamut of the liberal credo, including such moral enormities such as divorce and remarriage, contraception, abortion, and homosexual "marriage").  Citizens who are clothed with the whole armor of God, which includes the belt of truth, the breastplate of justice, the sandals of the Gospel of peace, the shield of faith, the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, are not so malleable.  (Eph. 6:10-17)

There is, however, an image other than the "naked public square" that might profitably be used to look at the efforts of secularists to control believers.  We might say that the secularists would like to see us all forced to live in an "iron cage."  I borrow that image from Steven D. Smith's book The Disenchantment of Secular Discourse, who himself borrows it from the famous German sociologist and political economist Max Weber.  Max Weber referred to modernity and its secularist assumptions as something that puts us in a stahlhartes Gehäuse, an "iron cage" or "hardened steel-like shell."

We moderns, Weber said, have voluntarily placed ourselves in an "iron cage" of secularism, a life where most of our public life is lived, and civil and political discourse is conducted, in purely secular terms.  Civilly and publicly we live life as if God does not exist, a life of practical atheism.  So-called "public reason"--which is the only reason allowed in the "iron cage"--does not allow God-talk, disdains Christianity, and positively despises Catholicism. 

The "iron cage" mentality explains why the Obama administration, acting through the Department of Health and Human Services in issuing the recent mandate, was totally deaf to the argument of the Church.  The Church's teaching on contraception, sterilization, and abortion--even though it is not based upon confessional truths, but based upon reasonable truths (i.e., the natural moral law)--is by an act of secular will not part of the "public reason" recognized by secularist liberals.  The Obama administration wants the Church to remain within the "iron cage."  It insists in a "naked public square."  Catholic truths, even if based upon reason, are to be "churched."

Within the "iron cage" of secular discourse, God and the Faith can be mentioned in completely vague and innocuous ways, but when it comes to implementing them or encouraging their practice in public displays (e.g., the Ten Commandments, Christmas crčches), or public ways (e.g., public school prayer), or in a publically-enforceable manner (e.g., in policy or law), the cry is quite clear and insistent: fuhgeddaboudit.

Some human activities work well when done in what Charles Taylor calls the "immanent frame" of the Weberian "iron cage."  When one enters into the "iron cage," one looks at everything in an empirical way, and it follows that those things that require empiricism as part of their essential thought work well within the iron cage's bars: so science as science, applied science (technology) as applied science, economics as economics, work well in an "iron cage." 

As the German philosopher Josef Pieper explained in his book on leisure, medieval philosophers called the kind of thinking that occurs within the "iron cage" ratio, discursive reason, which leads to scientia.  This kind of thinking was distinguished from the kind of thinking known as intellectus, or contemplation, which leads to the higher form of knowledge called wisdom, or sapientia.

It is a paradigm mistake to think that because some activities--namely, those that involve ratio--work well in the "iron cage" all activities work well in the "iron cage." 

In fact, some human activities--those that involve what one may call the "Life Questions"--cannot be performed in the "immanent frame" of the "iron cage."  What is man?  What are we made for?  What is truth?  What is good?  What is evil?  How are we to live with others?  Does God exist?  Is God mindful of man? 

To answer these questions, we must leave the "immanent frame" of the "iron cage," and enter into a "transcendent frame."  This requires a different way of thinking, the exercise of a deeper reason: intellectus as distinguished from ratio.  The intellectus is open to questions of God as ultimate reality.  Intellectus leads to the threshold of faith--fides--and through faith to divine wisdom, sapientia divina.

The "Life Questions" are the most fundamental questions we confront as humans.  To require--as the secularists do--that we try to answer these questions in the "iron cage" of secular liberalism is a fool's quest.  Science cannot answer, nor will it ever be able to, answer the "Life Questions."  They have to be answered, if they are going to be answered at all, outside the "iron cage."

A large part of Westerners, including Americans, have bought the notion of life in an "iron cage."  We are in large part like dogs at animal shelters.  Dogs seem happy enough to live out of the cold and in their warm kennels which are nothing less than "iron cages."  Like dogs, we have been trained voluntarily to go into and stay in our "iron cages."  Most of us seem happy enough docilely to live in "iron cages" as long as we are let out on a periodic basis to frolic about so that we can eat, drink, do drugs, watch pornography, have sex with whomever we wish whenever we wish without responsibility, and thereby, so the old saw goes, be merry.  He who dies with the most orgasms and the most toys wins, presumably.

In his allegory on the Christian life entitled Pilgrim's Progress, the Puritan author John Bunyan has a guide named Interpreter take the protagonist named Christian into a very dark room where he sees a man in an iron cage.  The man in the iron cage is an allegorical figure representing an apostate.  We might adopt this apostate--the man in an iron cage--as a symbol of secular liberalism, a secular liberalism which represents the last whiffs of a dismantled Christendom which long ago rejected Christ, and now reviles Christ.

The man, Bunyan tells us, "seemed very sad; he sat with his eyes looking down to the ground . . . and he sighed as if he would break his heart." 

Christian asks the man in the iron cage, suggesting he is something less than a man, an animal or even a thing: "What art thou?"  To which question the man answered enigmatically, "I am what I was not once."   Christian's interest is piqued by this strange reply, and so the following dialogue ensues:

CHRISTIAN: What wast thou once?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE: The man said, I was once a fair and flourishing professor, both in mine own eyes, and also in the eyes of others:  I once was, as I thought, fair for the celestial city, and had then even joy at the thoughts that I should get thither.

CHRISTIAN: Well, but what art thou now?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE:  I am now a man of despair, and am shut up in it, as in this iron cage. I cannot get out; Oh now I cannot!

CHRISTIAN: But how camest thou into this condition?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE: I left off to watch and be sober:  I laid the reins upon the neck of my lusts; I sinned against the light of the word, and the goodness of God;  I have grieved the Spirit, and he is gone;  I tempted the devil, and he is come to me;  I have provoked God to anger, and he has left me: I have so hardened my heart, that I cannot repent.

The scene and the dialogue obviously rattle Christian, and he turns to Interpreter his guide and asks whether there is any hope for the man in the iron cage.   The Interpreter encourages Christian to ask the man in the iron cage just that question.  So the dialogue re-ensues:

CHRISTIAN: Is there no hope, but you must be kept in the iron cage of despair?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE: No, none at all.

CHRISTIAN: Why, the Son of the Blessed is very pitiful.

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE:  I have crucified him to myself afresh, I have despised his person, I have despised his righteousness; I have counted his blood an unholy thing; I have done despite to the spirit of grace, therefore I have shut myself out of all the promises and there now remains to me nothing but threatenings, dreadful threatenings, faithful threatenings of certain judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour me as an adversary.

CHRISTIAN: For what did you bring yourself into this condition?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE: For the lusts, pleasures, and profits of this world; in the enjoyment of which I did then promise myself much delight: but now every one of those things also bite me, and gnaw me like a burning worm.

For the Puritan Bunyan, the man in the iron cage could no longer repent and turn.  The Calvinistic God of steely double predestination, a juggernaut of a doctrine, would not allow it. 

CHRISTIAN: But canst thou not now repent and turn?

THE MAN IN THE IRON CAGE: God hath denied me repentance. His word gives me no encouragement to believe; yea, himself hath shut me up in this iron cage: nor can all the men in the world let me out. Oh eternity! eternity! how shall I grapple with the misery that I must meet with in eternity?

But the answer of Bunyan's dour Calvinism is not the answer a Catholic Christian would give.  Is there a way out for the man in the "iron cage"?  According to Pope Benedict XVI, there is.  In our next article, we shall look at what Pope Benedict XVI believes is the door out of the "iron cage" of modern secularism, and where the man in the iron cage may find the key.  


Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas.  He is married with three children.  He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum.  You can contact Andrew at


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'

Copywriter 2015 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for October 2015
That human trafficking, the modern form of slavery, may be eradicated.
Evangelization: That with a missionary spirit the Christian communities of Asia may announce the Gospel to those who are still awaiting it.


More Living Faith

Come together this Thanksgiving with a beautiful prayer Watch

Image of Each year thousands of families celebrate Thanksgiving, but make the food their priority. This year, make God and all He has given us your priority.


Each year, millions of people across the United States rush to grocery stores and prepare to visit their families in celebration of Thanksgiving. Visiting loved ones and enjoying a specially prepared meal are both wonderful parts of celebrating, but don't forget to ... continue reading

Pope Francis: Jesus is weeping over a WORLD AT WAR

Image of Pope Francis mourns a world at war.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Pope Francis has made it clear, Jesus is weeping over a world at war. It has become obvious that this is a time of extreme danger for all people around the globe. No population is safe from terror. The threats aren't just from terrorist organizations like ISIS and Al ... continue reading

Oxford to begin study of Catholic relics. Here are 5 macabre relics people venerate from around the world Watch

Image of The skull of St. Thomas Aquinas.


The veneration of relics in the Catholic Church has been one of the most debated practices in the faith. While such veneration is actually common in the human experience -even Communists did it with the body of Lenin, the veneration of relics in the Church is the ... continue reading

Nine bishops, one abbot, dine and dialogue with peace activists Watch

Image of

By Tony Magliano

During the recent U.S. Catholic bishops' fall assembly in Baltimore, several bishops and one abbot, decided to skip dinner at the downtown Marriott Waterfront hotel, and walked several blocks to an inner city parish to share a simple meal with about 30 peace ... continue reading

Woman turns her cancer over to Jesus Christ - survives, thrives Watch

Image of Heather King shares her struggles in her new memoir,

By Mary Rezac, CNA/EWTN News

Heather King never cared much for doctors. Los Angeles, CA (CNA) - It's an attitude she partly inherited from her mother, "who classified ginger ale as a medicine, considered Novocain a snobbish extravagance" and somehow managed to avoid a visit to the doctor's office ... continue reading

Top 5 ways to find joy Watch

Image of Find happiness in spite of the darkness.


It is easy to fall prey to depression and sadness with everything that has been going on in the world these days. The trick to maintaining a positive attitude and living in the joy God has for us is as easy as following five simple steps. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic ... continue reading

Want to lose the War on Christmas? Surrender Advent Watch

Image of What millions of Christians do a day after expressing thanks for what they already have.

By Marshall Connolly, Catholic Online (THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Want to lose the War on Christmas? Surrender Advent. We Christians have gone out of our minds, arguing about Starbucks cups and greeters who (correctly) say "Happy Holidays" in place of "Merry Christmas." In all the bustle of the season, we have forgotten that Advent ... continue reading

Cardinal Sarah releases new book, 'God or Nothing,' on civilization's fall from grace Watch

Image of Without God, the cardinal said,

By Elise Harris, CNA/EWTN News

At the presentation of his new book, Cardinal Robert Sarah said that Western society is rapidly forgetting God, and expressed his desire to help people rediscover him through both prayer and witness. Vatican City (CNA/EWTN News) - "I would like to help people ... continue reading

Holy Door in St. Peter's basilica to open for first time in 15 years for Holy Year of Mercy Watch

Image of The rite of the opening of the Holy Door is intended to symbolically illustrate the idea that the Church's faithful are offered an

By Elise Harris, CNA/EWTN News

Hidden since the Jubilee of 2000, the Holy Door in St. Peter's Basilica was revealed Tuesday as the brick wall covering it was removed in anticipation of the Holy Year of Mercy launching next month. Vatican City (CNA/EWTN News) - Cardinal Angelo Comastri, the ... continue reading

5 powerful Bible verses you need when fear and terror strike Watch

Image of


Fear is a powerful thing. Fear can completely cripple the body and soul. Since the terrifying Paris terrorist attacks last week the news has been full of death, terrorists, murder and fear. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Those not in power are left wondering ... continue reading

All Living Faith News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

the FEED
by Catholic Online

  • Daily Readings for Saturday, November 28, 2015
  • St. Catherine Laboure: Saint of the Day for Saturday, November 28, 2015
  • Prayer For Courage HD Video
  • BIGGER THAN ISIS - There's a hidden power behind ISIS and it's so big ...
  • The Miracle Prayer HD Video
  • President likens Syrian refugees to pilgrims on Mayflower in ...
  • 'Black Friday' leaving bruises as shoppers trample each other for ...

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Daniel 7:2-14
2 Daniel said, 'I have been seeing visions in the night. I saw that the ... Read More

Psalm, Daniel 3:75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81
75 Bless the Lord, mountains and hills, praise and glorify him for ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 21:29-33
29 And he told them a parable, 'Look at the fig tree and indeed every ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for November 27th, 2015 Image

St. James Intercisus
November 27: James was a favorite of King Yezdigerd I of ... Read More