Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Brian Hanson

3/10/2014 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

Do Americans know what freedom is?

Americans love freedom - but do they really know what freedom is?

Only God can give us real freedom.

Only God can give us real freedom.

Highlights

By Brian Hanson

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

3/10/2014 (2 years ago)

Published in Blog

Keywords: Religious Freedom, American Catholic Church, Freedom, Gay Marriage, God, truth, faith,


WASHINGTON, DC - Perhaps many would respond by saying freedom is the non-coercive capacity to choose. What would they choose? Anything that appeals as a good for them.

While it may be true that freedom entails non-coercion, it does not mean having an unbridled capacity to choose whatever one thinks or feels is good for them.  In such a notion of freedom - prevalent in liberal societies (like the United States of America) - what is good is not so much the thing chosen, but the sheer ability to choose things. The free American is not defined so much by what he chooses, as by the fact that he is capable of choosing anything. In this truncated form of freedom, the goodness of the thing chosen is secondary; in fact it is only
good' so long as it is 'chosen.'

Light a virtual candle today


However, this is a perversion of what freedom truly is. It is not the sheer capacity to choose that makes a person free, but the reality of an actual good that exists prior to any choice. You can only freely choose something if that something really exists as a good in the first place.

Here's an example that draws on a hot issue in our culture today: the goodness of marriage:

A man and woman who choose marriage are free because marriage as such already precedes their choice as a good in reality. A man and a man (or a woman and a woman) who 'choose 'gay marriage' cannot be said to be truly free, for 'gay marriage" does not truly exist as a good; it does not even exist in the first place.  In this context, 'gay marriage' needs to first be 'created' (because it doesn't actually exist) in order to be 'chosen' (which is a deception: a false freedom).  In this case, the actual good (marriage as it exists in reality) is rejected, and defying common sense, freedom becomes identified with a non-good ("gay marriage").

This may appear to be an over simplification of what freedom is (and isn't), and the example may also appear to be short-sighted for not taking into other factors that effect a person's freedom (such as sin). All that withstanding, the basic premise still remains: true freedom goes beyond the mere capacity to choose - freedom rests on a good that exists, and to which freedom is ordered.

In our American culture, we think that religious freedom means being able to choose your own religion.  At first blush, this seems to be a trustworthy definition of religious freedom; but think again.  For Catholics in America, it is important to be clear about this. Jesus Christ is not a mere option, and he is not just for Christians. He is the truth that sets everyone free; in a word, he is the true good that exists in reality, the one who reveals the meaning of human life. He is - in other words - for all human beings, and exists not a mere option, but as the Good that exists for all in reality.

To recap: true freedom does not consist choosing between endless indifferent options.  True freedom goes beyond choosing by allowing what is truly good to move the chooser to affirm that good. 

Freedom has been made possible for us because the Good to which we are moved toward - Jesus Christ - has first come to us.  This freedom certainly goes beyond its deficient form in our American culture.
 

---


'Help give every student and teacher Free resources for a world-class moral Catholic education'


Copyright 2017 - Distributed by THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for DECEMBER 2016
Universal:
End to Child-Soldiers: That the scandal of child-soldiers may be eliminated the world over.
Evangelization: Europe: That the peoples of Europe may rediscover the beauty, goodness, and truth of the Gospel which gives joy and hope to life.



Comments


More Blog

Life Is Seasonal - Embrace It

Image of

By Jackie Stammen

I've been reflecting much on the idea of seasons in our life lately.  NASHVILLE, TN - Seasons come and they go, it's inevitable. It's true for the kind of seasons that relate to weather but what I' m really talking about is the seasons of our lives. We often find ... continue reading


You Can't 'Untruth' THE Truth

Image of

By Jackie Stammen

Sometimes it smacks you in the face and sometimes it's a gradual, almost unnoticeable acquisition, but when you learn Truth, you can't "untruth" it.  NASHVILLE, TN - I'm talking about Truth of the Gospel, Truth of faith, and Truth of The Way. Once you learn it, ... continue reading


This Is Amazing Grace Watch

Image of

By Norm LeDonne

Amazing grace. King of glory. Worthy is the Lamb that was slain. A traditional Christian spiritual. The Old Testament. The New Testament. What do these three things have in common? They are all lyrics in the Phil Wickham song "This is Amazing Grace." This young ... continue reading


I Kissed His Feet

Image of

By Michael Seagriff

God calls all of us to walk the Via Dolorosa with Him, to spend time at the foot of His cross, to be there as He is nailed to it, to be there throughout the entire three hours of His agonizing death, to be there as He is taken down from the cross, to be there as He is ... continue reading


Your Name Rules The Atmosphere Watch

Image of

By Norm LeDonne

Jesus was born to save us from our sins, to bring us hope and to show us how to love. He is the source of our peace. We look to him for all of these things and more. What is more fitting than calling on him and recognizing all that he has done for us? <a ... continue reading


2017: 5 Ways to Start Anew

Image of

By Chaplain Adele M. Gill

The New Year is upon us and with it we get all get to start anew. What better way is there to start the New Year? It is a great time to look ahead to see where we want to be this time next year and switch gears to meet our new goals - new plans, new perspectives, new ... continue reading


3 Easy Steps to Growing in Gratitude

Image of

By Chaplain Adele M. Gill

I have a friend who tells me she gets pretty sentimental each New Year's Eve. Like so many people, looking back over the year - and looking ahead at the upcoming year - she has a blend of both nostalgia and anticipation. Nostalgia for all the good times, successes and ... continue reading


Joy To The World! Watch

Image of

By Norm LeDonne

"<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLT9dSt8cwg">Joy to the World</a>" is a traditional and popular Christmas carol. The lyrics to the carol were first published in 1719. The music is attributed either to George Frideric Handel or Lowell Mason. In ... continue reading


A Christmas and Eucharistic Reflection Watch

Image of

By Michael Seagriff

Imagine this Christmas that before exchanging gifts with family and friends, Jesus thanks you for the greatest gift you could have possibly given Him. What might that be? Interested? Listen to this podcast.Merry Christmas![media id="16661"]     continue reading


The Truth of A Charlie Brown Christmas Watch

Image of What keeps A Charlie Brown Christmas on the air year after year is because it speaks to the truth we all know in our hearts: the true meaning of Christmas!

By Michael Clark

After 49 years, Charlie Brown still outclasses all the other Christmas specials. For sure it was the first of many animated holiday specials, but it is its truth that keeps it the best of them all. DENVER, CO - First broadcast in 1965, A Charlie Brown Christmas set the ... continue reading


All Blog News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Hebrews 9:2-3, 11-14
2 There was a tent which comprised two compartments: the first, in which ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 47:2-3, 6-7, 8-9
2 For Yahweh, the Most High, is glorious, the great king over all the ... Read More

Gospel, Mark 3:20-21
20 He went home again, and once more such a crowd collected that they ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for January 21st, 2017 Image

St. Agnes
January 21: St. Agnes of Rome was born in 291 AD and raised ... Read More