Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Leticia Valasquez

3/23/2010 (5 years ago)

Catholic Media Review (

"Amish Grace" is an original film by the Lifetime TV Channel that will run this Sunday March 28 at 8:00 PM EST/5:00 PM PST.  It will replay on the west coast at 9:00 PM PST.


By Leticia Valasquez

Catholic Media Review (

3/23/2010 (5 years ago)

Published in TV

DALLAS, TX (Catholic Media Review) - They called themselves the ´plain people´ and are characterized by their distinctive lifestyle and dress. They are the Amish of Lancaster County, PA. Still living without electricity or motor vehicles, and within a closed community, the Amish attract a lot of attention from tourists who are curious about why they live without modern conveniences and dress in traditional garb.    On October 2, 2006, in Nickel Mines, the Amish attracted an entirely different type of attention. Charles Carl Roberts, backed up his pickup truck to the the community´s one room schoolhouse where he proceeded to tie up and shoot 10 girls execution style, killing five, before taking his own life.

The innocence of the girls Charlie shot and his own admission that he was a sexual predator with intent to abuse again, held the world in the grip of horror. This was the third school shooting that first week of October 2006; however it stood apart from the others by its diabolical nature. The shooter had deliberately targeted the pacifist Amish community because their lack of technology meant that they were more vulnerable.  He knew this because for years he had driven a milk truck, collecting milk from their farms. They trusted him and he betrayed their trust by shooting of their girls in a premeditated assault because as he stated in his suicide note, Charlie was mad at God for taking his newborn daughter who died 10 years earlier.

Rather than recoiling further from ´the English´, the Nickel Mines Amish community visited the home of Charlie Robert  the afternoon after the murders, offering his widow Amy their condolences and telling her that they forgave her husband. It was an unprecedented act of mercy that left the local news team flummoxed. A reporter for the local news station is sent to cover the story and becomes involved in the life of Ida Graber, an Amish woman who is struggling to forgive her daughter´s killer.

At first she is curious about the true motives behind the extraordinary act of kindness on the part of the community elders which include Gideon, Ida´s husband. Because Ida has trouble accepting their actions, she suspects that they do not represent the wishes of the entire community, and that they are imposing the impossible upon their members. Ida has come to the end of her rope, and begs to be driven to her sister Emma´s home in Philadelphia, ending her marriage, since her husband will shun her, as her sister was shunned when she left the community to marry a non-Amish husband.

She forms a friendship with Ida, offering her a way out of the Amish community. Kimberly Williams-Paisley is Ida Graber, the Amish mother or a slain 14 year old whose crisis of faith is less than believable, a case of Hollywood trying to make sense out of a culture which mystifies them. Let the mystery stand, the Amish have their own reasons for remaining apart from the world, and the film does an admirable job revealing the true nature of the Amish.

Tammy Blanchard is passionate as Amy Roberts the widow of the murderer Charlie who was conducting a prayer meeting while her husband was shooting school children. She is s a good wife and mother, who is devastated by her husband´s crimes. She is profoundly moved by the compassionate visit of the Amish on the very day of the murder/suicide, and becomes a distant friend of the community as they rebuild the New Hope schoolhouse.  

 In the opening scene, the Amish community gathers for a Sunday service and the Deacon says than an English man asked him why they keep themselves separate. He explains, "We are separate, so that we do not stray. Someone who boasts that he is a Christian must walk in the path of Christ. Then he said to me, ´cqn you not walk In path of Christ and watch television too?´ (laughs) I said, well, would be quite the trick. How can we keep our minds on God if we are distracted by worldly pursuits? We cannot.  We keep our lives simple so that our path to Heaven will be wide open for us. Let us lift our voices now in expectation in arrival in our true home".
The Heavenly-mindedness of the Amish is the inspiring theme of Amish Grace, and even the faith of a practicing Christian like Amy Roberts pales in comparison to the glowing example of faith in God and unquestioning obedience to His will seen in the Amish community. In the season of Lent when we examine ourselves to see where the world has crept into our hearts, comparison of our own willingness to forgive to that of the Amish community could be a moment of grace. Amish grace.

No direct violence, nudity or strong language. Highly recommended for the whole family, since the shootings are not portrayed in the film and sexual abuse is not mentioned, however  the discussion of murder may be frightening for younger children.


More TV

New 'X-Files' series wows viewers at TV trade fair Watch

Image of The new

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The new six-episode series of TV fan favorite "The X-Files" wowed viewers at the MIPCOM television trade fair this week. Off the air since 2002, the series, with its blend of science fiction and paranoia has long been a science fiction favorite - and if the ... continue reading

Mystery, excitement surrounds 'X-Files' reboot Watch

Image of Whether it was aliens of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Mulder and Scully - actors David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson, respectively, return to battle against the forces of the unknown in the hotly anticipated "The X-Files" reboot. Principal photography has wrapped, and some exclusive photos have made their way out ... continue reading

Historical Heroines: New show to feature women who need to be remembered Watch

Image of Women who have changed the course of history.

By Atarah Haely

History has always told us about heroes and great warriors, but seldom do we hear stories of heroines and great female warriors. With many edited out of textbooks and discussions, a new BBC series will be dedicated to the women who changed the course of history.  ... continue reading

White House confirms Obama will appear in reality show 'Running Wild with Bear Grylls' Watch

Image of Survivalist Bear Grylls [not pictured] will help President Barack Obama across the Alaskan wilderness in his reality TV show 'Running Wild with Bear Grylls.'


Barack Obama will be the first-ever sitting president to join survivalist Bear Grylls in a special edition of his reality show <i>Running Wild with Bear Grylls</i>. The White House confirmed that the commander-in-chief will challenge his survival skills in ... continue reading

Cord-cutters on the move: Record number of Americans ditching cable TV services for the Internet Watch

Image of Perhaps tiring of paying for channels they never watch, many viewershave chosen to ditch Pay TV altogether for free online streaming.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Many young people - as well as many older Americans, are ditching their pay TV for Internet streaming. In an example of "watching what you want - when you want," consumers are flocking to the ease of online streaming. Called "Cord-cutters" or "cord nevers," ... continue reading

HUSH, HUSH: They deny - but NBC invests $250 million in BuzzFeed Watch

Image of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

A major media organization is laying out a pretty penny in order to be seen as "cutting edge" and "trendy." NBCUniversal is reportedly investing $250 million in BuzzFeed at a $1.5 billion valuation. BuzzFeed is a hyperkinetic, colorful news Web site dedicated ... continue reading

Showtime series breaks boundaries, features ISIS, Putin and Snowden Watch

Image of Photo from Homeland season 4.


The fifth season of Homeland will take on a major geo-political personality, including the Muslim extremist group, ISIS, and Russia's president, Vladimir Putin. This thriller television series has been relocated to Germany after it was pulled from the Middle East. ... continue reading

Catching the summer 'stream' on Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hulu Watch

Image of The Kevin Costner classic

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The summer heat is at its peak in the month of August. Do the only sensible thing to do - and watch movies on TV in air-conditioned comfort. Here's a list of films and original content coming to streaming services for the final month of summer. LOS ANGELES, CA ... continue reading

TV adaptation of Colombia's only saint frustrates devotees Watch

Image of


For weeks now, promotional ads have been spotted announcing what claims to be Colombia's next huge prime-time television sensation. However, several controversies have emerged over this TV adaptation that dramatizes the life story of Colombia's only Roman Catholic ... continue reading

Live televised exorcism to occur inside the infamous house that inspired 'The Exorcist' Watch

Image of


Destination America will show a live exorcism from inside the house that inspired both the novel and film "Exorcist," six decades later. For the upcoming special, "Exorcism: Live!," the team will exclusively film in the suburbs of St. Louis, Missouri. This will be the ... continue reading

All TV News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Malachi 3:13-20
13 'You have said harsh things about me, says Yahweh. ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 1:1-2, 3, 4, 6
1 How blessed is anyone who rejects the advice of the ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 11:5-13
5 He also said to them, 'Suppose one of you has a ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for October 8th, 2015 Image

St. Pelagia
October 8: Pelagia, more often called Margaret, on account of the ... Read More