I’m trying to understand, Mr. Obama, but it just doesn’t make any sense. Why would you work so methodically to increase the occurrence of something so ‘heart-wrenching’?
If the choice to 'terminate a pregnancy' through abortion is merely about a woman’s right to privacy and autonomy, there should be nothing difficult about it at all. If there are no grounds to declare it illegal, inhumane, or morally wrong, then indeed there should be no conflict of the heart whatsoever.
CHESAPEAKE, Va. (Catholic Online) - I have in front of me a letter I received from you in response to a letter I wrote to you regarding abortion in the U.S. You thanked me politely for taking the time to share my views on abortion and said, “This is a heart-wrenching issue.”
I just haven’t been able to get one little question out of my mind since reading your letter. Why?
Why is it heart-wrenching? Why would my heart be rent by making a perfectly legal and morally acceptable choice to have an abortion? Why should anyone’s heart be torn by this choice? The highest law of our land says that there is nothing wrong with choosing abortion. If no law is being broken, why should my heart or anyone’s heart be troubled?
In the short time you’ve been President, you have strategically worked to expand abortion access around the country. In fact, you promised in your campaign that your first task upon taking office would be to sign into law the Freedom of Choice Act, which would eliminate virtually every existing restriction on abortion throughout all nine months of pregnancy, and even lift the ban on partial-birth abortion. (You said you considered that one a legitimate medical procedure.)
I’m trying to understand, Mr. Obama, but it just doesn’t make any sense. Why would you work so methodically to increase the occurrence of something so heart-wrenching?
As a woman, I can testify to the fact that when I make decisions to protect my privacy or the autonomy of my body, there’s nothing heart-wrenching about it. I am not the least bit torn or conflicted about defending myself in those ways. Indeed, it is my body – the one God gave me and the one He expects me to care for wisely and honorably. My body – like yours – was made to be holy.
If the choice to “terminate a pregnancy” through abortion is merely about a woman’s right to privacy and autonomy, there should be nothing difficult about it at all. If there are no grounds to declare it illegal, inhumane, or morally wrong, then indeed there should be no conflict of the heart whatsoever.
But you and I both know that is not the case, because you and I both know quite well that there is something very, very morally wrong with abortion.
No one can pretend the other person in this equation doesn’t exist. No one – not even you – can deny that abortion ends a human life. Whether the medical profession classifies that person as an embryo, a fetus, or a newborn, the indisputable fact is we’re talking about a new human being. Not an eggplant or a seahorse. This person is not an extension of her mother’s body, but a distinct, separate individual with her own body and soul.
Abortion does not tear the mother’s body limb from limb, or burn her body with chemicals, or suction her body into a vacuum, or stab a hole in her skull and suction out her brains. Abortion does all these hideous things to another human being. That is the reality of this wretched “choice.”
No thinking, civilized person can deny it. We all know in our hearts, in the depths of our souls that abortion kills a human person. There is a very strange and powerful sort of delusion going on, then, for that is the only way to explain how so many people can stubbornly, arrogantly and blindly cling to the notion that abortion is legitimate “reproductive health care” and a “right” of all women.
I ask you again: what is so heart-wrenching about availing myself of legitimate reproductive health care?
Those who demand abortion rights must constantly prop up the illusion in their minds that they’re not hurting anyone or doing anything wrong. It helps their cause to use more palatable language, like “terminating a pregnancy” rather than killing a baby. (Mr. President, I’ve been pregnant four times and I can assure you that every single time, I was pregnant with a baby. The only way to terminate a pregnancy is to terminate the baby.)
Ah, the baby… could that be the source of all the heart-wrenching? But we’ve already decided we’re not going to even acknowledge the humanity of the baby, so what’s the problem? Just get rid of the unwanted tissue already and be done with it.
"Pro-Choice" advocates must continually shout the mantra of “women’s rights” in order to keep from thinking about the mangled little body lying on the instrument table after the “procedure.” If they stop for even a moment to consider the actual results of abortion, all arguments for its legality would necessarily collapse in a heap around them. No one with an ounce of humanity could stomach this gruesome brand of “medicine” without the protection of narcissistic and evil delusions of choice and rights.
The enemy of every human soul has deceived and deluded us into rationalizing the unjustifiable murder of our own children. You ...
Thank you Jennifer and Jean. The day after I wrote the post I realized I was in another one of my 'moods'. I read back over my posts and thought that they might very possibly be portraying non-charity. Though I could be confusing firmness with uncharitable; I don't know.
Robert | 8/31/2009
NICHOL GOLYAR GOD BLESS YOU AND IM GLAD AS CATHOLIC YOU WERE BORN.
YOU AND MANY OTHERS MAKE A DIFFERENCE TO.
Love to all who stand by the true teaching of the Catholic Church.
Jean | 8/31/2009
TOUCHING LETTER. WE JUST HAD A RALLY HERE IN NEBRASKA PEOPLE BOTH PROTESTING FOR AND AGAINST ABORTIONS AT DR. CARHARTS OFFICE. (WHICH IS ONE OF THE FEW TO DO THIRD TERM ABORTIONS)IN JUST THE FRIDAY THEY PICKETED THERE WERE OVER 30 APPTS.IT'S HARD NOT TO CRY TO THINK OF THAT, ALONE. I WROTE A LETTER SIMILAR TO THE PRESIDENT. MY MOTHER HAD ME IN HIGHSCHOOL AND ABORTION WAS SOMETHING PUSHED BY FRIENDS AND EVEN SOME FAMILY. TO THINK THAT I, MY CHILDREN, THE POSITIVE I'VE DONE FOR THOSE AROUND ME. NOTHING WOULD BE IF THAT CHOICE WAS MADE!!I CAN'T PUT THAT FEELING INTO WORDS!! HERE IS TO THE HOPES FOR OUR FUTURE AND OUR CHILDRENS FUTURE.
GOD BLESS
NICHOL
Comments that include profanity, personal attacks, antisocial behavior such as "spamming" and "trolling," or other inappropriate comments or material will not be posted on Catholic Online. Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. We will take steps to block users who violate any of our terms of service. While Catholic Online invites robust discussion, we maintain the right to not print material that is patently false in its claims concerning the teaching of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church, overtly anti-Catholic or which, in the opinion of the moderator, are intended to mislead readers as to what the Catholic Church teaches. Comments DO NOT necessarily reflect the opinion or views of Catholic Online.