Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Douglas W. Kmiec

11/6/2008 (6 years ago)

Catholic Online (

"Deacon Fournier is, of course, absolutely right: these pro-choice positions are not what the Catholic Church prays for, and so we shall keep praying."

The greatest challenge for truly Pro-life Americans is, through prayer, persuasion and activism to work to protect the lives of innocent unborn children under this new administration while we continue our efforts to build a new culture of life and civilization of love in America and around the world.

The greatest challenge for truly Pro-life Americans is, through prayer, persuasion and activism to work to protect the lives of innocent unborn children under this new administration while we continue our efforts to build a new culture of life and civilization of love in America and around the world.


By Douglas W. Kmiec

Catholic Online (

11/6/2008 (6 years ago)

Published in Politics & Policy

MALIBU, California (Catholic Online) - As the readers of Catholic Online know very well,Professor Doug Kmiec and I disagreed quite seriously on how a faithful Catholic citizen should approach the exercise of their vote in this recent Presidential election in the United States. This strong disagreement over proper moral decision making and human action led to many articles and exchanges. However, the election is now over. We have a new President Elect, Barack Obama. I communicated with Doug following the election and he sent me the following article asking that it be published. (Deacon Keith Fournier, Editor) :

"Obama's Miracle"

There was a miracle in America Tuesday evening. Pro-life and Pro-choice views on abortion met in Chicago's Grant Park and in similar settings across the nation. Each respected the other's perspective and each understood how they could both work, differently, to promote human life.

The Catholic bishops in their "Call to Faithful Citizenship" document urged us to vote responsibly knowing that no candidate in the race was perfect. Senators McCain and Obama both varied from the absolute prohibition of abortion and embryonic stem cell research in Catholic teaching. Senator McCain favors turning "the choice" back to the states; while, Senator, now President-elect, Obama respects the woman's decision.

Deacon Fournier is, of course, absolutely right: these pro-choice positions are not what the Catholic Church prays for, and so we shall keep praying, but as President-elect Obama articulated in his acceptance last night - the hill may be steep, but we will continue to climb. And no Catholic should be distraught at this happy moment when race has been transcended and there is a promise of both social justice and peace at hand.

We owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to those bishops who did not violate our conscience, or theirs, by stepping into the role of partisan advocate for a candidate, or who even more outrageously, presumed to consign to eternal damnation those Catholic voters who studied, prayed, and formed their conscience prior to casting a ballot for Senator Obama. Neither man was eliminated from Catholic consideration. Neither was pro-abortion. After ascertaining that, it was up to each voter to consider the totality of Catholic teaching on the culture of life -- from the moment of conception to the moment of natural death and every point in between in order to give due weight to proportionate considerations.

While we must continue to strive to structure our personal lives and the larger society to honor life to the full, let us not overlook the miracle of a free election naming as President someone who a century and a half removed would have not even been acknowledged to be a created human being entitled under the Declaration of Independence to the unalienable rights of life, liberty or the pursuit of happiness.

Now is also the time to work together in the joy of new hope and fresh ideas. I have extended a hand of friendship to Archbishop Chaput who some told me had some especially harsh words for me because of his strongly held view against Senator Obama. It's a free country and the First Amendment protects the Archbishop's political perspective as well as mine own. And likewise in the exposition of the faith, the Conference of Bishops, knowing how to write with sensitive and fine grain pen, gave us both the opportunity to best assess how to promote human life within the context of a Republic of many different religious beliefs some of which see life beginning when a child is born alive and not before.

Of course, as John Paul II taught in Veritatis Splendor, no democracy should set itself against the truth of the human person. When John McCain proclaimed himself to be "pro-life," many thought we would hear from him a call for some effort to bring the Constitution in line with the protection of life. Ronald Reagan was a champion of this idea though he did not succeed in achieving it. The Reagan amendment would have included the unborn in the constitutional definition of "person" and it had the benefit of simplicity. Yet, given again the related criminal liability for mother and doctor, it lacked the support needed for ratification.

Is there another way to show legal respect for life? Obama's own cultural affirmation of enhanced support for the expectant mother points the way toward common ground. In this regard, a more modest constitutional amendment could be pursued that would presume life to begin at conception, while further providing that no government, federal or state, was competent to legislate on the question absent a specified supermajority. This would at least take the Supreme Court's "activist" thumb off the scale against life (no more waiting for a "fifth justice") while at the same time avoiding the criminalization of a women's freedom. Again, not the ideal Catholic position, but closer.

Going forward with our new President, it is likely that looking for new ways to be pro-life will hold more promise than re-arguing the merits of an election that brought a miracle our ancestors did not foresee. That same election miracle may hold the promise of yet another the outline of which may at this moment only be dimly perceived; namely, an amendment to our basic charter presuming life to begin from its earliest moment even if that would still leave it up to us to find the necessary supermajority or additional ways to honor that legal presumption consistent with our many faiths and collective freedom.

Impossible? I don't see why. In the language of the moment: "Yes we can!"

Douglas W. Kmiec is the Caruso Family Chair & Professor of Constitutional Law at Pepperdine University School of Law and the author of "Can a Catholic Support Him? Asking the Big Question About Barack Obama" (Overlook/Penguin 2008)


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'

Copywriter 2015 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for October 2015
That human trafficking, the modern form of slavery, may be eradicated.
Evangelization: That with a missionary spirit the Christian communities of Asia may announce the Gospel to those who are still awaiting it.


More Politics & Policy

Kevin McCarthy quits speaker race amid allegations of affair with Renee Ellmers Watch

Image of Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) pictured with Renee Ellmers (R-NC)


According to Washington insiders, Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) is having an affair with Renee Ellmers (R-NC). McCarthy dropped out of the Speaker race, and may have done so because an unknown insider is circulating a surveillance video on Capitol Hill, of him dining with ... continue reading

President Obama faces uphill battle with Pacific Rim trade pact Watch

Image of The Trans-Pacific Partnership is being battered on both sides of the right and the left in the U.S.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

United States President Barack Obama has hailed the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) the largest free-trade agreement in a generation, as its completions will open new markets for U.S. goods and services. While Obama says the agreement will give "our workers the fair ... continue reading

California Governor Jerry Brown signs 'End of Life Option Act' Watch

Image of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

California Governor Jerry Brown has signed the "End of Life Option Act" into law this week. While he remained largely ambiguous about the bill, he came forward with the statement that the "Crux of the matter is whether the state of California should continue to ... continue reading

Trans-Pacific Partnership faces criticism in Congress Watch

Image of Citizen protests the Trans Pacific Partnership (AFP).


The controversial Trans-Pacific Partnership has been finalized and will be presented to business leaders by US President Barack Obama. However, Congress has already shown skepticism over the pact. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Twelve countries in the Pacific Rim ... continue reading

#IAmaChristian: Ben Carson honors the Oregon shooting's fallen students Watch

Image of Ben Carson (Facebook).


Nine were shot dead during the recent horrifying shooting at the Umpqua Community College in Roseburg, Oregon where a student claimed the gunman specifically targeted the religious. Following the claim, Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson started a social ... continue reading

Supreme Court to render decisions on sensitive topics of abortion, birth control, race Watch

Image of An even more pressing issue to go before the court will be the issue of religious freedom coupled with President Obama's health care reform.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The Supreme Court is rolling up its sleeves to render decisions that have long roiled the United States: abortion, birth control, religious freedom, and race. None of the pending decisions is likely to have the same import as the recent decision regarding ... continue reading

False ambassador has been working in government affairs for five months Watch

Image of Brett McGurk (C-Span).


For five months, an Obama administration official falsely presented himself as an official U.S. ambassador.  LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Brett McGurk, who is a deputy special presidential envoy to the Global Coalition serving under General John Allen, was ... continue reading

Will slow and steady win presidential race? Bernie matches Hillary with far smaller donations Watch

Image of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Longtime - if recently troubled political warhorse Hillary Clinton and avowed socialist Bernie Sanders are currently duking it out for the lead in the Democratic Presidential Race of 2016. Something highly significant has emerged in the contest ... the poor, ... continue reading

Donald Trump meets with 40 religious leaders and prays Watch

Image of Donald Trump meets religious leaders inside the Trump Tower.


Forty religious leaders and pastors met with presidential candidate Donald Trump in his Trump Tower office Monday afternoon. Trump shared a few minutes of prayer with the religious leaders, some of whom are noted televangelists. LOS ANGELES, CA  (Catholic Online) ... continue reading

DOUBLE DIPPING? Hillary Clinton aide paid by consulting firm to while also with State department Watch

Image of Some sources agreed to describe Huma Abedin's work for Teneo on the New York event, along with her subsequent work at the State Department for a Teneo-connected event in Ireland four months later in December.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

There are new revelations that Huma Abedin, Hillary Clinton's confidante, was paid both by the State department alongside the private consulting firm Teneo Holdings. Recent newspaper reports say Abedin staged a star-studded reception that included her boss' ... continue reading

All Politics & Policy News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Malachi 3:13-20
13 'You have said harsh things about me, says Yahweh. ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 1:1-2, 3, 4, 6
1 How blessed is anyone who rejects the advice of the ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 11:5-13
5 He also said to them, 'Suppose one of you has a ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for October 8th, 2015 Image

St. Pelagia
October 8: Pelagia, more often called Margaret, on account of the ... Read More