Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Mark Henry and Keith A Fournier

6/29/2012 (4 years ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

The US Supreme Court has just unleashed a new controversy which will frame the Presidential campaign of 2012.

The Supreme Court's surprising decision to uphold the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, not under the Commerce Clause, but as an exercise of Congress' power to tax, shocked the press, confused the Nation and sent the experts - and the lawyers - to read, re-read, analyze and parse the lengthy and complex opinion. This dense opinion was authored for a 5- 4majority by Chief Justice John Roberts. Justices Kennedy, Alito, Scalia and Thomas dissented. The decision sets the stage for what will be the most hotly contested presidential election in decades.

Artists rendering of the argument

Artists rendering of the argument

Highlights

By Mark Henry and Keith A Fournier

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

6/29/2012 (4 years ago)

Published in U.S.

Keywords: Obamacare, Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Constitution, Article VI, United States Supreme Court, Religious Freedom, Mandate, Separation of Powers, Executive Order, Department of Health and Human Services, Health Care Rationing, Contraception,


WASHINGTON, DC (Catholic Online) - On Thursday, June 28, 2012, while a pensive Nation watched, the Justices of the United States Supreme Court spoke on the constitutionality of the individual mandate of the Affordable care Act (aka Obama Care). The Supreme Court's surprising decision to uphold the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, not under the Commerce Clause, but as an exercise of Congress' power to tax, shocked the press, confused the Nation and sent the experts - and the lawyers - to read, re-read, analyze and parse the lengthy and complex opinion. This dense opinion was authored for a 5- 4majority by Chief Justice John Roberts. Justices Kennedy, Alito, Scalia and Thomas dissented. The important decision has now set the set the stage for what will be the most hotly contested presidential election in decades. The opinion upholding the individual mandate of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act ("Obamacare") is complex and lengthy. So complex, that the eager media got it wrong.at least initially. The Supreme Court did hold that the mandate requiring Americans to purchase health insurance was unconstitutional under the Constitution's Commerce Clause. That led to the widespread and inaccurate reporting that the mandate was struck down. It was not! The individual mandate was upheld, just resting upon a different legal basis, Congress' power to tax. However, the language in this lengthy opinion on other constitutional law will serve as an important marker. It will serve to limit the Federal Government's ability to use the Commerce clause to regulate the behavior of the States and private citizens in future cases. The effects and aftermath of this controversial law will not end with today's Supreme Court ruling.  The majority opinion, while upholding the disputed penalty provision as a tax, made it clear the Justices did not "pass upon its wisdom". However, this law stands and the reaction has just begun. The foundation upon which it stands may matter little as it relates to the public policy implications and the real effect on the lives of many people. Then again, there is a lot of the opinion left to read! The net effect of this opinion has yet to be assessed. Ironically, the Obama Administration initially argued that the penalty for non-compliance with the Affordable Care Act's mandate to purchase insurance was not a tax. However, they changed their position as the argument unfolded on the day of argument in the Chambers of the Court. Like thousands of lawyers around the Nation, we will digest this complex, dense and surprising opinion and return with further analysis. However, it is important to remember that this Case is not the end of the legal challenges to this massive legislative scheme. The other constitutional issues which result from its implementation, such as the unconstitutional violation of the Free Exercise of Religion precipitated by the HHS Mandate, have given rise to numerous lawsuits on their way to the same Court. In fact, those cases, which might have become moot had the Court struck down the Act, now become monumentally important. In addition, the US Supreme Court has just unleashed a new controversy which will frame the Presidential campaign of 2012.
----- Mark Henry is an attorney and founder of Legal Lifeguard, Inc.a provider of Catholic Pro-Life Medical Protection documents.  Get your Free Lifeguard Emergency I.D. Card.  Keith A. Fournier is an attorney who spent much of his legal career in constitutional law and engaged in public policy issues at the intersection of faith and culture. He serves as the Editor in Chief of Catholic Online. 

---


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'


Copyright 2016 - Distributed by THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for SEPTEMBER 2016
Universal:
Centrality of the Human Person: That each may contribute to the common good and to the building of a society that places the human person at the center.
Evangelization: Mission to Evangelize: That by participating in the Sacraments and meditating on Scripture, Christians may become more aware of their mission to evangelize.



Comments


More U.S.

St. Michael the Archangel, Defend Us in Battle: Pope Francis Takes on the Devil Watch

Image of St Michael doing battle with Satan

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Now the new People of God is the Church. That is the reason she considers him her protector and support in all her struggles for the defense and expansion of the kingdom of God on earth. It is true that "the powers of death shall not prevail", as the Lord assured ... continue reading


Shocking train wreck leaves trail of complete destruction, but only three deaths -- Was this St. Michael's intercession? Watch

Image of A train crashed into the Hoboken train station, leading to several deaths and injuries.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

A New Jersey transit train crashed into the Hoboken station Thursday morning in the midst of rush hour - Luckily, today is St. Michael's feast day and by his intercession, the crash wasn't as bad as it could have been. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Train no. 1614 ... continue reading


Why won't Obama say the phrase 'radical Islamic terrorist?' Watch

Image of Why won't Obama say 'Radical Islamic Terrorists?'

By David Drudge (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Obama refuses to use the phrase "radical Islamic terrorist" when speaking about the Islamic State and other Islamic terror organizations. He explained this refusal during a town hall discussion on CNN. LOS ANGELES, CA (California Network) - President Obama refuses to ... continue reading


Lazy, spoiled, craven millennials claim the Christian cross is hate speech and other ridiculousness Watch

Image of Shown: various forms of hate speech.

By David Drudge (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

The safest thing to say about a safe space is that they've gone too far. Today's college students want safe-spaces, gun-free zones, and to be coddled in every way. As a result, we're producing a generation of weak, adult-age children who cannot think or do anything for ... continue reading


Obama KNEW Clinton was on a private server, used a fake name in his emails Watch

Image of Obama has no excuse. He should have known what Clinton was doing. Why the pseudonym?

By David Drudge (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Here may be the real reason Hillary Clinton was never indicted by the Obama administration. Obama was in on Clinton's email scandal from the start. According to new emails released by the FBI, Obama spoke with Clinton on her private server, but used a pseudonym to ... continue reading


Learning Holy Courage and Living Faith from the Book of Job Watch

Image of Job and his accusing friends

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Job did not follow God just because He was so good to him, but because He is God. So should we. When we encounter the inevitability of loss, suffering, difficulties and persecution in our lives, as we certainly will, we should beware of the fairweather friends of ... continue reading


Historic Statement Affirms the Catholic Church's Teaching on the Gift of Sexuality Watch

Image of

By Marshall Connolly (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

A small body of Catholic scholars and religious have issued a statement dissenting from the teaching of the Catholic Church on the gift of sexuality, marriage and contraception. The statement was issued by the "Wijngaards Institute for Catholic Research" and calls on ... continue reading


Major relic of St. Padre Pio in the United States Watch

Image of Padre Pio.

By Mary Rezac (CNA/EWTN News)

The Capuchin keepers of the relics of the late mystic Padre Pio are sending the saint's heart to Boston for his feast day. Boston, MA (CNA/EWTN News) - "I'm very excited to announce that the Capuchin Friars who run the Shrine of St. Padre Pio have offered to come to ... continue reading


Summit Declaration: Use These Principles to Compare Candidates and Platforms in the Upcoming Elections

Image of American Flag and Bible

By THE STREAM

The Church is the light of truth and the salt that preserves society. We realize that the state of our country now is partly our responsibility. If America is troubled, it means that we have failed to waken it to the principles that could grant it peace and ... continue reading


Protests in Charlotte, N.C. turn violent - It's time for a change in attitudes Watch

Image of Maybe pull your pants up first?

By Marshall Connolly (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Protesters ran riot in downtown Charlotte, NC on Wednesday night, as they vented frustration over the killing of a disabled man by police. Keith Lamont Scott was shot and killed by police on Tuesday. Police say he had a gun, while others contend the police mistook a ... continue reading


All U.S. News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Job 38:1, 12-21; 40:3-5
1 Then from the heart of the tempest Yahweh gave Job his answer. He ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 139:1-3, 7-8, 9-10, 13-14
1 [For the choirmaster Of David Psalm] Yahweh, you examine me and know ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 10:13-16
13 'Alas for you, Chorazin! Alas for you, Bethsaida! For if the miracles ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for September 30th, 2016 Image

St. Jerome
September 30: St. Jerome, who was born Eusebius Hieronymous ... Read More