Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

3/21/2012 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

The way I seek to effect a reconciliation between the two is to distinguish between the order of justice and the order of mercy

The question of capital punishment within the Catholic Church is a thorny one, and it is difficult within the cacophony of competing voices to sort out the current state of the Church's teaching. The Church's teaching that relates to the intentional killing of an innocent human being by either public authority or a private actor is certain.The teaching of the Church on the killing of a malefactor-specifically as found in Pope John Paul II's Evangelium vitae and the editio typica of the Catechism of the Catholic Church-is not quite as absolute

An electric chair

An electric chair

Article Highlights

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

3/21/2012 (2 years ago)

Published in U.S.

Keywords: capital punishment, death penalty, Gospel of Life, common good, justice, mercy, Andrew M. Greenwell


CORPUS CHRISTI, TX (Catholic Online) - The question of capital punishment within the Catholic Church is a thorny one, and it is difficult within the cacophony of competing voices to sort out the current state of the Church's teaching. 

The Church's teaching that relates to the intentional killing of an innocent human being by either public authority or a private actor is certain.  It is an absolute and exceptionless norm that the intentional killing of an innocent human being is in each and every case an intrinsic evil, against the natural moral law, and a violation of the Fifth Commandment.  It is a sin against justice and against charity.  EV, 57, 62, 65, 71.

The teaching of the Church on the killing of a malefactor-specifically as found in Pope John Paul II's Evangelium vitae and the editio typica of the Catechism of the Catholic Church-is not quite as absolute, and hence the uncertainty.  EV, 57. 

Before he was pope, Cardinal Ratzinger himself recognized this in a letter to the U.S. Bishops dated July 3, 2004, where he recognized that "if a Catholic were to be at odds with the Holy Father on the application of capital punishment . . . he would not for that reason be considered unworthy to present himself to Holy Communion."  While urged to "exercise discretion and mercy . . . it may still be permissible . . . to have recourse to capital punishment."

Without suggesting that I have the final word on the matter which is in a little state of flux and which better minds than mine have struggled, I have tried to do two things in this very short treatment. 

First, I have tried to preserve the traditional teaching of the Catholic Church that the death penalty may be justly applied by public authority, i.e., that it is not a moral evil and in fact is a moral good, in a proper case, to put a malefactor to death for a serious capital offense.  I believe that teaching to be irreformable.  But I have also tried to give John Paul II's teaching in Evangelium vitae which has found its way into the Catechism of the Catholic Church its full and plenary meaning without quibbling.  And taking both teachings, I have attempted to reconcile the two.

The way to I seek to effect a reconciliation between the two is to distinguish between the order of justice and the order of mercy.  As St. Ambrose put it in his letter to the Christian judge Studius, "authority, you see, has its rights, but mercy has its policy." 

In Evangelium vitae, with respect to the malefactor and the "problem of the death penalty," John Paul II is not focusing on the rights of authority in the order of justice to execute a malefactor, but on mercy's policies.  He is balancing two goods: one of justice and one of mercy.

Within the order of justice, for the public authority to put a malefactor guilty of a capital offense to death is no wrong.  It is justified by the good of retributive or vindicative justice, and the public authority, as custodian of the common good, has that power given to it by God.  It is certainly an evil in the physical order, but it is a moral good in the order of justice

This is the constant teaching of the Church, and it is found in the Old Testament (e.g., Gen. 9:6, Ex. 21:12; Lev. 24:17), and New Testament (e.g., Rom. 13:1-7), and from St. Clement of Alexandria, to St. Thomas Aquinas, to St. Alphonsus Liguori, the Gratian, to Popes Innocent I and Innocent III to Pius XII.  Indeed, I find it to be consistent with John Paul II's teaching in Evangelium vitae, who observes that while an innocent's life has absolute value, a malefactor's life is not likewise so absolute.  EV, 57.

However, the order of justice is not the only order that informs the good.  There is also an order of mercy.  If a malefactor may justly be put to death, there is the further question: is there room for mercy?  And if so, when?

In Evangelium vitae, Pope John Paul II provides the analysis for the limits of mercy within the context of the death penalty.  Adopting the analysis that is used when a private party defends against an unjust aggressor, the Pope teaches that mercy may theoretically extend as far out to the point where "absolute necessity" requires otherwise, in other words, "when it would not be possible otherwise to defend society."  EV, 56.  This is the outer limit for mercy. 

To go beyond this limit would be to expose society to danger, and that would be uncharitable, unmerciful, indeed unjust.  St. Thomas says that mercy without justice is dissolution.  Misericordia sine iustitia mater est dissolutionis.  The public authority may not forego justice and exercise mercy on a malefactor guilty of a capital offense if the result would be to expose the public to harm.  Obviously, the better the "organization of the penal system," the less the exercise of mercy exposes the public to harm.  This is a contingent circumstance public authority must consider in exercising clemency.

In answering the question of when a malefactor who justly could be put to death ought to be the beneficiary of mercy, the responsible public authority must consider other contingent circumstances, such as the "concrete conditions of the common good," including the "public order."  For example, the public authority might consider that there is a "growing tendency, both in the Church and in civil society, to demand that it [the death penalty] be applied in a very limited way or even that it be abolished completely." EV, 56. 

The reason why this is a proper consideration is that the larger the proportion of the populace opposed to the death penalty is, the lesser the sense that such a punishment is required for vindicating the order of justice.  While the malefactor might justly be put to death objectively without moral fault, the "public order" might not share in the sentiment that the malefactor ought to be put to death. 

On the other hand, if the public sentiment is the opposite, the "public order" might demand that mercy not be extended to the fullest theoretical limits.  An example of this is if granting clemency to a justly condemned malefactor would almost certainly result in rioting by the population.

Moreover, the public authority should consider the intrinsic dignity of the malefactor, who, though he has "marred" his dignity and has "deform[ed] the image of God in his own person," has not effaced it, and in fact never can efface it.  EV, 36, The malefactor remains a human being whose fundamental ontological dignity is unaffected despite his crimes, and is the potential subject of God's grace and conversion.  After all, he still has a soul.  It is the traditional teaching of the Church that the conversion of one soul is worth the entirety of material creation.  It is a manifest, extraordinary good.  It is a pearl of great price.  (Matt. 13:45)

That is the meaning behind the parable of the lost sheep, where the good shepherd leaves the ninety-nine that are safe, and is solicitous for the one who has gone astray (Matt. 18:12-14; Luke 15:3-7).  The good of mercy exceeds the good of justice on a scale of 99:1.  The Church, says the Venerable John Henry Newman, "holds that it were better for sun and moon to drop from heaven . . . than one soul, I will not say, should be lost, but commit one single venial sin."  The exercise of clemency to allow a man more time to convert to God is a great good.

Iustitia sine misericordia crudelitas est says St. Thomas Aquinas in his commentary on the Gospel of Matthew.  "Justice without mercy is cruelty."  There is great good in mercy.

Even if there is some incremental good in the order of retributive justice that is lost by letting a man guilty of a capital offense live through clemency, the good in the order of mercy potentially gained, given the value of the conversion of a human soul, is vastly great and very arguably a better thing.

Finally, the times the Christian is enjoined to have mercy as mercy was had on him in the Scriptures is so prevalent as to resist citation.  In a nutshell, the Gospel message is as Pope St. Nicholas I (r. 858-67) put it in his letter to the Bulgars: "You should save from death not only the innocent, but also criminals, because Christ has saved you from the death of the soul."  Here is Pope St. Nicholas speaking in the order of mercy.

To the cry of "injustice!" from a man justly condemned to die, Christians will turn a deaf ear, for this is not true.  But to the cry of "mercy!" from a man justly condemned to die, Christians will pause.  It is in this forum--not of justice, but of mercy--where the sinner, the malefactor will always have an audience, and one that is biased in his favor.

Sure.  We may be resistant, like Shylock in Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice.  "On what compulsion must I?  Tell me that!"  Our sense of justice may be offended.

Though there be no compulsion of justice (and therefore no mortal sin), there is a sort of compulsion of mercy.  Justice must be tempered by mercy.  Shakespeare restates what we know to be the better virtue when he has Portia say in response to Shylock's question:

But mercy is above this sceptered sway.
It is enthroned in the hearts of kings.
It is an attribute to God himself.
And earthly power doth then show likest God's
When mercy seasons justice.


We might also here adopt the prayer of St. Anselm of Canterbury which applies to all of us malefactors, for all of us have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.  (Rom. 3:23).  We all, like sheep, have gone astray. (Isaiah 53:6)

Parce per clementiam,
Ne ulcisaris per iustitiam.


Spare in mercy;
Avenge not in justice.

-----

Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas.  He is married with three children.  He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum.  You can contact Andrew at agreenwell@harris-greenwell.com.

---


Pope Francis calls for your 'Prayer and Action'


© 2014 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for March 2014
Respect for Women:
That all cultures may respect the rights and dignity of women.
Vocations: That many young people may accept the Lordís invitation to consecrate their lives to proclaiming the Gospel.



Comments


More U.S.

Suffering, Struggle and the Christian Revolution Watch

Image of

By Deacon Keith Fournier

The Christian tradition instructs us that even undeserved and unmerited suffering, when joined in love to the sufferings of Jesus Christ, can produce extraordinary fruit within us - and then through us, as we change. This is a part of the teaching on the mystery ... continue reading


FORCED BESTIALITY: Evil teenage girls sexually assault autistic boy - and record it for posterity Watch

Image of Seventeen-year-old Lauren Bush along with her 15-year-old accomplice are accused by the St. Mary's County sheriff's department on numerous charges.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

In an episode shocking for its sheer cruelty, two teenage girls in Maryland are now in custody after they repeatedly abused a 16-year-old autistic boy - eventually making him perform sexual acts with a family pet - and recording it all on their cell phones. LOS ... continue reading


HOW LONG BEFORE THE SYSTEM BREAKS? Working Americans increasingly made to pay for those on welfare Watch

Image of Those who work in America are increasingly being made to pay for those who don't -- in the manner of an over-burdened ox.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

If you're an American who awakes each day to begin a day of toil you have no interest in, take heed: There are only more reasons to hit your pillow in frustration each night as you drift off to sleep. You are an endangered species, and the media has not rallied ... continue reading


Ron Paul warns Feds may stage 'Waco styled' raid Watch

Image of Cliven Bundy has been fighting with the Bureau of Land Management for 20 years over his cattle and grazing rights.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

While Cliven Bundy, his family, their supporters, and myriad militiamen forced federal agents from the Bureau of Land Management to back off of the Bundy's Nevada ranch and release hundreds of captured cattle, one politician warns that the feds could be planning ... continue reading


What does this say about America? More people getting food stamps than women working full-time Watch

Image of There were only 15,678,000 women who worked full-time, year-round in the United States in 1969.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

It's a distressing figure that shines a most unflattering light on affairs here in the United States. According to recent statistics, those  participating in the food stamp program, or SNAP outnumbered the number of women who worked full-time, year-round ... continue reading


Palm/Passion Sunday: Will We Make This Week Holy By Encountering Jesus Christ? Watch

Image of Holy Week invites us to let go of self and embrace the Lord Jesus anew through saying Yes to the invitation to continuing conversion. How desperately we all need to hear the Good news that we can begin again!

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Palm/ Passion Sunday: Make This Holy Week a Deep Encounter With Jesus Christ!During this week called Holy, the Lord Jesus is extending His saving Hand to each one of us anew. The timeless one has broken into time and now transforms it from within. The question is ... continue reading


Living Among the Pharisees Watch

Image of Christ Before the High Priest

By Deal W. Hudson

I will not quote directly from the article - there is no need to infect readers with the Phariseeism pervading Ruse's psychological/spiritual analysis of Thomas Williams. The readers can judge for themselves. I've been the target of similar, and worse, ... continue reading


Time for a Movement Rooted in the Real Social Doctrine of the Church Watch

Image of

By Deacon Keith Fournier

Christian social teaching challenges any notion of human freedom which begins and ends with the isolated, atomistic, person as the measure of its application. We are by nature and grace called to relationship. Only in communion can we become fully human and find ... continue reading


Nevada cattle rancher has won fight with feds -- for now Watch

Image of Clive Bundy claims his herd of roughly 900 cattle have grazed on the land along the riverbed near Bunkerville, 80 miles northeast of Las Vegas, since 1870.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

For the time being, Nevada cattle rancher Cliven Bundy has appeared to have won his week-long battle with the federal government. His case has spurred nationwide attention, and has garnered protestors rallying for his rights.  LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic ... continue reading


Is Pope Francis Opening the Possibility of Ordaining Mature, Proven Married Men to Priesthood Watch

Image of

By Deacon Keith Fournier

The prophetic witness of voluntary, consecrated celibacy has endured beyond the ranks of celibate clergy. It is also preserved in the inspired vowed life of monastic orders and the sacrificial witness of religious men and women. In addition, in many of the ... continue reading


All U.S. News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Isaiah 52:13--53:12
13 Look, my servant will prosper, will grow great, ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 31:2, 6, 12-13, 15-16, 17, 25
2 turn your ear to me, make haste. Be for me a ... Read More

Gospel, John 18:1--19:42
1 After he had said all this, Jesus left with his ... Read More

Reading 2, Hebrews 4:14-16; 5:7-9
14 Since in Jesus, the Son of God, we have the ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for April 18th, 2014 Image

St. Apollonius the Apologist
April 18: Martyr whose Apologia, or defense of the faith, is considered ... Read More

Inform, Inspire & Ignite Logo

Find Catholic Online on Facebook and get updates right in your live feed.

Become a fan of Catholic Online on Facebook


Follow Catholic Online on Twitter and get News and Product updates.

Follow us on Twitter