Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Ronald J. Rychlak

5/2/2008 (8 years ago)

Inside Catholic (www.insidecatholic.com)

Regardless of what it is called, legal sanctioning of homosexual relationships creates a host of unintended consequences and constitutes a serious threat to religious liberty.

In an atmosphere which is becoming increasingly charged and filled with accusations and allegations, little consideration is being given to the legal implications of so called 'same sex' marriage and marriage equivalency laws as they affect the constitutional right to religious freedom.

In an atmosphere which is becoming increasingly charged and filled with accusations and allegations, little consideration is being given to the legal implications of so called "same sex" marriage and marriage equivalency laws as they affect the constitutional right to religious freedom.

Highlights

By Ronald J. Rychlak

Inside Catholic (www.insidecatholic.com)

5/2/2008 (8 years ago)

Published in U.S.


WASHINGTON, DC (Inside Catholic) - America's position on homosexual activity has radically changed over the past few decades.

Fifty years ago, every state criminalized homosexual acts under "sodomy laws." As recently as 1986, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of such laws.

In 2003 there were still 13 states that criminalized homosexual acts (though the laws were rarely enforced). That year, however, the Supreme Court ruled these laws unconstitutional. Today, laws are used to protect rather than prohibit homosexual activities.

The supreme courts in California and Connecticut are about to decide whether same-sex couples have a right to marry in those states. Massachusetts already granted homosexuals that right.

Vermont, Connecticut, New Jersey, and New Hampshire all have civil unions, which are similar to marriage, but activists in those states are already pointing to deficiencies and pushing for full recognition of gay marriage.

Regardless of what it is called, legal sanctioning of homosexual relationships creates a host of unintended consequences and constitutes a serious threat to religious liberty.

Consider what happened in Massachusetts in 2004: Justices of the peace who refused to preside over same-sex unions due to moral or religious objections were summarily fired. Since same-sex unions were entitled to be treated the same as traditional marriages, this refusal was discrimination and a firing offense.

What about a priest or minister who similarly refuses to preside at such ceremonies? Obviously the state can't fire such people, but it is easy to foresee other sanctions -- such as loss of tax benefits -- being imposed on churches.

After all, if gay marriage truly is no different from traditional marriage, by what justification can the government give preferential treatment to an entity that discriminates?

Just last year, two women filed a complaint in New Jersey because they were denied use of a pavilion for their civil union ceremony. The pavilion was owned by a Methodist ministry. It had been rented out for marriages, but the ministry refused to rent it for civil unions because it is a religious structure, and civil unions are not recognized in the United Methodist Church Book of Discipline.

Due to the ministry's refusal to rent it for the lesbian ceremony, New Jersey revoked its tax-free status.

The Des Moines Human Rights Commission found the local Young Men's Christian Association in violation of public accommodation laws because it refused to extend "family membership" privileges to a lesbian couple that had entered a civil union in Vermont.

Accordingly, the city forced the YMCA to recognize gay and lesbian unions as "families" for membership purposes, or lose over $100,000 in government support.

Perhaps the most notorious example of a state forcing its view on a church agency comes from Massachusetts, where Boston Catholic Charities ran an adoption agency that had been placing children with families for over 100 years.

In 2006, Archbishop Sean P. O'Malley announced that the agency would abandon its founding mission rather than submit to a state law requiring it to place children with homosexual couples. (A Vatican document from 2003 described gay adoptions as ''gravely immoral.")

The legal analysis in these cases is really pretty simple:

If homosexual marriages or civil unions are the equivalent of traditional marriages, you can't discriminate. If you do, at the very least you put your government benefits at risk.

This is the same rationale that was used by the Supreme Court in 1983 to uphold stripping Bob Jones University of its tax-exempt status due to its racial policies.

A potentially greater threat is that government agencies will try to change church teachings. It is already happening in other nations.

The Catholic Church, for instance, teaches that homosexual inclination is a "tendency toward an intrinsic moral evil; and thus the inclination itself must be seen as an objective disorder."

Bishop Fred Henry of Calgary, Canada, was investigated by the Alberta Human Rights Commission for doing little more than writing about this teaching in a newspaper column. ─╣ke Green, pastor of a Pentecostalist church in Sweden, was tried, convicted, and sentenced to a month in prison for a sermon that insulted homosexuals.

It may seem that legal recognition of civil unions or gay marriages is a trivial matter and one that respects the basic dignity of gay people. The unintended legal consequences that flow from such recognition, however, present a serious threat to religious liberty.

Courts and legislatures need to consider these consequences before committing the nation to a policy with so many potential pitfalls.


Ronald J. Rychlak is the associate dean and MDLA Professor of Law at the University of Mississippi School of Law. He is the author of Hitler, the War, and the Pope (2000) and Righteous Gentiles (2005).

---

The mission of InsideCatholic.com is to be a voice for authentic Catholicism in the public square.We believe that truth is both attractive and compelling and that in the marketplace of ideas, it will invariably win out.



Comments


More U.S.

SPECIAL REPORT: James Robison Interviews Eric Trump, Pt 2: Service and Sacrifice

Image of Father and son. Donald and Eric Trump

By James Robison and Eric Trump

Catholic Online received special permission to republish this two part interview between James Robison and Eric Trump, the son of the Republican nominee for the Presidency of the United States. Yesterday, we offered part one of the interview where James and Eric ... continue reading


Catholics Must Vote to Defend the Right to Life and End the Crime of Abortion Watch

Image of Crucifix on an American flag

By Deacon Keith Fournier

With the Presidential election in the United States upon us the allegations of "single issue politics" are again being leveled against anyone who condemns procured, legal abortion as immoral and evil. This is happening not only in the broad circles of American ... continue reading


Murdered Nuns: Fellow Sisters and family ask court not to execute killer Watch

Image of Rodney Earl Sanders confessed to murdering Sisters Margaret Held and Paula Merrill in their Mississippi home.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Despite murdering Sisters Margaret Held and Paula Merrill, family members and other Sisters continue to publicly oppose the execution of Rodney Earl Sanders. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Forty-six-year-old Sanders admitted he was responsible for the murder of ... continue reading


SPECIAL REPORT: James Robison Interviews Eric Trump on Faith, Fathers and the Inner City

Image of James Robison and Eric Trump

By James Robison and Eric Trump

Catholic Online received special permission to republish this two part interview between James Robison and Eric Trump, the son of the Republican nominee for the Presidency of the United States. Today, we offer part one of the interview where James and Eric ... continue reading


Ken Blackwell: Arizona Attorney General Brnovich Defends the First Amendment

Image of Ken Blackwell is a Senior Fellow for Human Rights and Constitution Governance at the Family Research Council. He serves on the Board of Directors of the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty

By Ken Blackwell

Jeffries was clearly not proselytizing or evangelizing, but did he somehow violate the separation of church and state because his emails touched on religion and the sacred? It's here that Watkins' analysis becomes both sublime and devastating. Why should Jeffries ... continue reading


Deacon Keith Fournier: Martyrdom of John the Baptizer Calls Us to Defend Marriage Watch

Image of The beheading of John the Baptizer

By Deacon Keith Fournier

John the Baptizer was beheaded. He died a martyrs death because he refused to deny the truth about the indissolubility of marriage and Gods eternal and unchangeable plan for marriage. We live in an age which also denies that truth. An age which goes even further ... continue reading


St. Augustine on a Personal Relationship with Jesus Watch

Image of St. Augustine

By Deacon Keith Fournier

But we too can encounter Christ in reading Sacred Scripture, in prayer, in the liturgical life of the Church. We can touch Christ's Heart and feel him touching ours. Only in this personal relationship with Christ, only in this encounter with the Risen One do we ... continue reading


Overdose crisis leaves investigators desperate to get dealers off the streets Watch

Image of Heroin overdoses have spiked in the last week.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

The use of fentanyl-laced heroin has resulted in an overdose crisis in the US over the course of a single week. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - According to Cincinnati.com, a rise in overdoses across the city has left police and emergency responders exhausted and ... continue reading


Five-year-old invents 'Kindness Day' Watch

Image of Five-year-old boy treats officers to a lunch from Subway.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Five-year-old William Evertz Jr. saved up his allowance for several months in hopes of purchasing a Power Wheels police car but realized his money would better benefit others. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - On Wednesday, the Winslow Police Department in ... continue reading


Two nuns found murdered in Mississippi home Watch

Image of Police have found two nuns slain in a Mississippi home.

By Marshall Connolly (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Two Catholic nuns have been found dead in their home after they didn't show up for their work. The pair worked as nurse practitioners out of state. Police are investigating the deaths of two Catholic nuns after they missed work. The pair were found together in a ... continue reading


All U.S. News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

the FEED
by Catholic Online

Daily Readings

Reading 1, First Corinthians 3:1-9
1 And so, brothers, I was not able to talk to you as spiritual people; I ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 33:12-13, 14-15, 20-21
12 How blessed the nation whose God is Yahweh, the people he has chosen ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 4:38-44
38 Leaving the synagogue he went to Simon's house. Now Simon's ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for August 31st, 2016 Image

St. Raymond Nonnatus
August 31: Raymond was born at Portella, Catalonia, Spain. ... Read More