Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

11/25/2012 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (

Our country would be better served if the Catholic Social Doctrine was better-known by our politicians, whether they be Catholic or not

Perhaps Americans can learn from the "Anthropological Emergency" manifesto and the efforts of the "Ratzingerian Marxists" Barcellona and Paolo.  God knows that our fractured society has lost the ability to communicate sensibly on those things which ought to guide our life in common and our political life.  The right and the left seem to yell past each other.


By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

Catholic Online (

11/25/2012 (2 years ago)

Published in Europe

Keywords: Ratzingerian Marxists, Pietro Barcellona, Paolo Sorbi, Anthropological Emergency, Andrew M. Greenwell

CORPUS CHRISTI, TX (Catholic Online) - Karl Marx and Josef Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) would seem to little in common.  Between a materialist atheist who believed in economic determinism and a man who believes in God and in moral freedom (and who was the bane of liberation theology) there would seem to be too large a no-man's-land for these two and their disciples to meet.

But faith is not so easily suppressed, and it sometimes finds admission and flowering in the least likely of souls. Recent events in Italy seem to prove this.  It is an odd phenomenon, but some of the Italian communist party, including such notables as Pietro Barcellona and Paolo Sorbi, have appeared to have abandoned Marxism and entered into the Catholic fold.

The reason?  Well, of course, God-who alone moves human hearts and gives the grace of faith.  But God also uses human instruments, and in this case the human instrument appears to have been Pope Benedict XVI.  For this reason, these Marxist converts to the faith have been called "Ratzingerian Marxists."  Perhaps a better name would be "Ratzingerian Ex-Marxists."

Pietro Barcellona, formerly a professor of Philosophy of Law and the University of Catania, and a former member of the Italian Communist party (PCI), was known as an avid exponent of Marxist atheistic materialism.  But in 2010, he stirred up quite a controversy when he announced his conversion to Catholicism.  Apparently, after the collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989, the staunch communist, materialist, and evolutionist walls that Barcellona had installed in his heart to keep out faith fell also.  

At first, philosophical nihilism seized him, but the non-God of materialistic evolution gives no comfort to the soul.  Life, and life's work become meaningless in a world which could just as well have done without you because it does not know you.  "The coming into the world of a human being has no meaning in the evolutionary sequence," Barcellona has said.

Something else had to be found to give meaning to his life.  God, of course, would make the cosmos friendly, since there would be a God behind the cosmos.  But Barcellona distrusted religion, as he saw it as a sort of "pure psychological projection," a comforting opiate perhaps, but no more. 

Eventually, however, Barcellona came to see that this cannot be said about Christianity.  "I was struck emotionally by the Gospel of Jesus Christ.  The birth of Christ, in fact, is an epochal rupture in the traditional way of seeing the relationship between God and the world, between what is divine and what is human.  It presents an absolute discontinuity with respect to all hypotheses regarding the understanding of God in all other religions."

Christ is the "zero point" of history: God and man met in one person.  Jesus is a historical fact, and not any psychological projection or dream induced by opiates.

In 2010, Barcellona wrote about his experience in a book entitled Encounter with Jesus.

Paolo Sorbi, former professor of sociology, is also a former Marxist and former member of the Italian Communist party and convert to the Catholic faith.  He currently heads up the Pro-Life office of the Archdiocese of Milan, and is the program manager of the Italian Catholic radio station, Radio Maria.

Barcellona and Sorbi, along with two other post-Marxist thinkers, the professor of history, Giuseppe Vacca, a philosopher and political scientist, Mario Tronti, joined forces in publishing a manifesto directed to the Italian left entitled "Anthropological Emergency: Towards a New Alliance Between Believers and Non-Believers." It was published in the Avvenire magazine on October 16, 2011, and it created a tremendous stir on the left.

The focus of the manifesto is on the serious threat to humanity based upon the technological manipulation of life through genetic manipulation and artificial conception.  It stresses the need for the left to take seriously the threat to mankind by these technologies, to dialogue with the Catholic Church and seriously consider the the anthropological and bioethical teachings of Benedict XVI, especially those with which he was responsible while Prefect of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, such as Donum vitae, and Dignitas personae.

"The manipulation of life" the manifesto begins, "originating in the developments of technology and of the violence inherent in the processes of globalization in the absence of a new international order, puts us in the presence of an unprecedented anthropological emergency.  This appears to us to be the most serious manifestation and at the same time the deepest root of the crisis of democracy.  It germinates challenges that demand a new alliance between men and women, believers and nonbelievers, religion and politics."

The manifesto calls for a new definition of secularism, one that is less hostile to religious values, recognizes the important public role of the Catholic Church and other religious bodies, and suggests for a greater balance of both faith and reason in the public arena. 

It suggests that the Church's social doctrine, which is founded on authentic human values, ought to be an inspiration to political parties, and can help bring some sort of commonality between all political parties so that debates are less polarizing. 

While the manifesto recognizes the autonomy of the political sphere vis-ŕ-vis the Church, that autonomy should not be construed as hostile to religious values or amoral.  The Church should be a partner in the development of society. 

The manifesto proclaims the need to guard against the danger of the "radical culture" of an overemphasized individualism which appears heedless to the truths and the good of social institutions and relationships, and results in a sort of tyranny of uncontrolled desire and uncontrolled application of technology as the only good.

It stresses the need to reject ethical relativism and to recognize that there are some values that are simply non-negotiable. 

The rejection of ethical relativism, the manifesto stresses, does not mean that the values of cultural pluralism need be rejected.  What it does require, however, is the rejection of morally nihilistic visions of modernity espoused by a minority of radical intellectuals.  Such moral nihilism can never be the basis for a democratic life.

Recognition of non-negotiable moral realities-one of which is the "freedom and dignity of the human person from the first moment of conception"-does not discriminate between believers and non-believers.  The authors of the manifesto frankly concede that this is the most criticized passage of the letter, and yet they view it as among one of the most important.

"To this end," the manifesto concludes "we believe that the Democratic Party should promote a public dialogue with the Catholic Church and other religious denominations operating in Italy and which are "ethically sensible," to the end that it might attend more strictly to the actual risks of the Italian nation: the state of its unity, and the  "ethical substance" of the democratic regime."

The manifesto, along with a fourteen separate essays commenting on the manifesto, has recently been published by the Italian publisher Guerini & Associates.

The authors of the manifesto have also announced a major conference that will include both Catholics and non-believers that will discuss the manifesto in 2013, and which will focus on the anthropological vision of Benedict XVI.

Perhaps Americans can learn from the "Anthropological Emergency" manifesto and the efforts of the "Ratzingerian Marxists" Barcellona and Paolo.  God knows that our fractured society has lost the ability to communicate sensibly on those things which ought to guide our life in common and our political life.  The right and the left seem to yell past each other.

Our society has become overly secularized and increasingly heedless to and even hostile to religious values.  The government seems intent on limiting religious freedom to freedom of worship and seems hostile to a broader, traditional view of religious freedom as including not only worship, but also public works of mercy.

All too often, we have adopted relativistic view of life, where "whatever floats your boat" is to be allowed, and where there are no such things as non-negotiables.  Our country would be better served if the Catholic Social Doctrine was better-known by our politicians, whether they be Catholic or not.

We have, moreover, trampled over some of those non-negotiables, most obviously that great non-negotiable that the "freedom and dignity of the human person from the first moment of conception" ought to be respected.


Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas.  He is married with three children.  He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum.  You can contact Andrew at


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'

Copywriter 2015 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for October 2015
That human trafficking, the modern form of slavery, may be eradicated.
Evangelization: That with a missionary spirit the Christian communities of Asia may announce the Gospel to those who are still awaiting it.


More Europe

Goodwill not welcomed everywhere as German TV show depicts 'Muslim Merkel' image Watch

Image of The producers of the show defended the image.


German Chancellor Angela Merkel's welcoming of Middle Eastern refugees is not being wholly embraced in her homeland. Complaints have risen about the sudden influx of Muslim immigrants in this largely catholic nation. ARD television broadcasted a mocked-up ... continue reading

CHURCH SHOCKER: Gay and pedophile priests sent to monastery for 'sex cures' Watch

Image of In the wake of recent sex scandals, it has been discovered that the Vatican sends priests

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

In the wake of recent sex scandals, it has been discovered that the Vatican sends priests "with inappropriate sexual tendencies" to a special monastery in the Alps for a purported cure. It has been learned that homosexual, pedophile and drug addicted clergy ... continue reading

Anti-Semitic violence runs rampant through Europe Watch

Image of


A top European Union official has warned of increasing anti-Semitism in Europe, as there are mounting threats and attacks against Jews in Europe's member countries.  BRUSSELS, EUROPE (Catholic Online) - The Vice President of the European Commission, Frans ... continue reading

Is ancient Greek tomb for Alexander the Great's friend Hephaestion? Debate continues Watch

Image of After his death in 325 B.C., Alexander the Great reportedly ordered that shrines be constructed throughout the empire. Hephaestion died less than a year before the Macedonian leader.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Archaeologist Katerina Peristeri declared that the mysterious Amphipolis monument is a tomb to Hephaestion, Alexander the Great's best friend who died less than a year before Alexander did.Fragmentary inscriptions link the monument to Hephaestion. Other archaeologists ... continue reading

10,000 copies of Germany's constitution was printed in Arabic to help nearly 800,000 migrants integrate Watch

Image of


Germany translated the first 20 articles of its constitution, which concerns basic rights such as freedom of speech, into Arabic for refugees to learn in an attempt to help immigrants integrate. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - At the moment, Germany struggles to ... continue reading

Segregation of Jewish and Muslim pupils in a French school echoes chilling Nazi segregation Watch

Image of


Jewish and Muslim students at the Piedallous primary school in Auxere, Burgundy were ordered to wear disks around their necks. The incident brought with it memories of Nazi segregation and caused an uproar. LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA (Catholic Online) - Daily Mail ... continue reading

German refugee camps plagued with rape and child abuse Watch

Image of The European migrant crisis continues to grow. Rape and sexual abuse are already being reported inside German refugee camps.


Rape and sexual abuse is now becoming a major problem in several German refugee asylums as the country tries to cope with their migrant crisis. HOLLYWOOD, CA (Catholic Online) - Refugees are facing several problems inside overcrowded refugee centers across the country ... continue reading

OVERRUN AND OUT OF PATIENCE: Immigrants quickly wear out welcome in Germany Watch

Image of In Germany, there are a few terrorist agents mixed in with those who say they are fleeing the brutal persecution of Islamic State, when in fact they themselves are ISIS.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Germany was lauded by the international community for taking in the large influx of immigrants feeling violence in Syria and Iraq. However . this generosity has a heavy price. Many of these so-called immigrants have left their native lands to make their ... continue reading

Expert confident forensic remains of fabled 'Mona Lisa' found Watch

Image of Most everyone is familiar with the image of a young woman with an enigmatic smile, her hands folded on her lap.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Leonardo Da Vinci's "Mona Lisa," perhaps the world's most famous painting, has cast a spell across the imagination. Lisa Gherardini, the wife of Florentine silk merchant Francesco del Giocondo, is thought to have been the portrait's model. Bone fragments have ... continue reading

British mother of six brutally assaulted in acid attack Watch

Image of Thirty-seven-year-old Carla Whitlock says that she is still trying to come to terms with how her life has been changed.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

In what is common in India - but most unusual in the United Kingdom, a 37-year-old mother of six is struggling to come to terms after suffering a vicious acid attack. Witnesses saw her face visibly melt, and doctors say she will probably lose the sight in one ... continue reading

All Europe News


Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Malachi 3:13-20
13 'You have said harsh things about me, says Yahweh. ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 1:1-2, 3, 4, 6
1 How blessed is anyone who rejects the advice of the ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 11:5-13
5 He also said to them, 'Suppose one of you has a ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for October 8th, 2015 Image

St. Pelagia
October 8: Pelagia, more often called Margaret, on account of the ... Read More