Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

6/26/2014 (2 years ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

As the Church has clearly taught, the common good demands that marriage be recognized in law as fundamentally and by nature limited to a life-long relationship between one man and one woman. It is only within this institution that sexual relations are a good.

The first step for a Catholic to recognize his obligation to oppose same-sex "marriage," if he does not see it or comprehend it, is to rid himself of the flawed moral heuristic (a moral rule of thumb or short cut) some ideologue has chosen and which may be blinding him to what is an obvious moral and political truth.

Highlights

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

6/26/2014 (2 years ago)

Published in Marriage & Family

Keywords: same-sex relationships, marriage, homosexuality


CORPUS CHRISTI, TX (Catholic Online) -  For many of us confronting the issue of same-sex "marriage," our thinking about it is deeply marred by the conventional heuristic.  A heuristic is a simple rule used by people to make decisions, including moral or political ones.  A heuristic is a mental shortcut, a rule of thumb, a quick and dirty application of common sense.

A heuristic can be a valuable tool in decision-making.  But a heuristic can be catastrophic if it is flawed.  A heuristic may be flawed because it is the wrong heuristic to be applied to a particular moral or political problem.  A wrong heuristic applied to a moral or political problem can wreak havoc in moral or political decision-making.  It can lead to systematic and institutional errors, even so-called "institutions of sin."

As an example taken from St. Thomas Aquinas, it is generally true that we are under an obligation in justice to deliver property placed under our care to its owner when the owner asks for it.  This is a good heuristic in almost all ordinary circumstances.  However, the heuristic is flawed if the owner that is requesting the sword has in the interim become mad, and returning the sword to him would result in harm to him or to others.  See S.T. Ia-IIae q. 62 a. 5 ad 1.

Sometimes the wrong heuristic is advanced as part of an ideological agenda, or for the purpose of obtaining a certain result or hiding the moral truth.  This is true for the moral and political debate involving same-sex "marriage."  The wrong heuristic is being advanced by the advocates of same-sex "marriage. " It creates horrible confusion, and results in wrong decision-making.

The heuristic that we are asked to use as a short-cut to thinking about same-sex "marriage" is framed in terms of love and equality.  We might call it the "love and equality" heuristic.  The "love and equality" heuristic goes something like this: Two persons who are in "love" should have an "equal" opportunity at marriage.

The "love and equality" heuristic works great in most areas.  For example, it is a perfect heuristic to be used against a miscegenist who advocates that marriage between two different races ought to be barred by law and public policy.  Applying the "love and equality" heuristic one can say, as a short-cut, that a black man and a white woman who are in love should have the same opportunity at marriage as a black man and a black woman or a white man and a black woman.  Any law that prevents this opportunity is therefore wrong.

However, the "love and equality" heuristic is flawed when applied to same-sex marriages.  The flaw comes from treating as morally equivalent the conjugal acts between a man and a woman committed to each other in a life-long, exclusive marriage (which are good independent of race) and homosexual genital activity.

If--as the natural moral law, Scripture, and the Church's moral teachings all hold--homosexual acts are gravely sinful, then the "love and equality" heuristic is flawed when applied to same-sex "marriage" questions.

As the Church has taught in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith's Considerations Regarding Proposals to Give Legal Recognition to Unions Between Homosexual Persons:  "There are absolutely no grounds for considering homosexual unions to be in any way similar or even remotely analogous to God's plan for marriage and family. Marriage is holy, while homosexual acts go against the natural moral law."

It would be wrong, therefore, for a Catholic to adopt the "love and equality" heuristic into the context of same-sex "marriage," because it directly contradicts the natural moral law, the teachings of Scripture, and the teachings of the Church.  Invariably, this thinking short-cut will lead him to the wrong conclusion.

The Catholic must rid himself of this flawed heuristic if he has adopted it.  And he should find one that more properly fits the moral and political issue that confronts him.  In fact, he has a moral obligation to apply a proper heuristic.  You cannot avoid moral obligations by the mere expedient of using a false moral heuristic.

As a proper heuristic in the context of same-sex "marriage," I would suggest turning to Evelyn Waugh's novel Brideshead Revisted.  In that novel, Waugh places these words in the mouth of Julia as she explains to her illicit lover Charles the Catholic notion of sin versus "living in sin."

"Living in sin, with sin, by sin, for sin, every hour, every day, year in, year out.  Waking up with sin in the morning, seeing the curtains drawn on sin, bathing it, dressing it, clipping diamonds to it, feeding it, showing it round, giving it a good time, putting it to sleep at night with a tablet of Dial [a barbiturate, a sleeping pill] if it's fretful."

To legitimize same sex "marriage" is to legitimize "living in sin, with sin, by sin, for sin, every hour, every day, year in, year out.  Waking up with sin in the morning, seeing the curtains drawn on sin, bathing it, dressing it, clipping diamonds to it, feeding it, showing it round, giving it a good time, putting it to sleep at night with a tablet of Dial if it's fretful."

It seems rather obvious that it is no moral or political good for a law to legitimize "living in sin, with sin, by sin, for sin, every hour, every day, year in, year out.  Waking up with sin in the morning, seeing the curtains drawn on sin, bathing it, dressing it, clipping diamonds to it, feeding it, showing it round, giving it a good time, putting it to sleep at night with a tablet of Dial if it's fretful."

It is impossible to spin the issue any other way.  Using the proper heuristic instead of a flawed one makes all the difference in the world. 

As the Church has clearly taught, the common good demands that marriage be recognized in law as fundamentally and by nature limited to a life-long relationship between one man and one woman. It is only within this institution that sexual relations are a good.  

The Church has also taught the common good demands that same-sex "marital" unions are farcical, ape real marriages, should be prohibited, and certainly never given the sanction or protection of law.  For this reason, a Catholic is morally compelled, under penalty of grave sin, to oppose same-sex "marriage" to the extent of his powers and influence, and certainly never see it or advocate it as a moral, political, or legal good.

The first step for a Catholic to recognize this obligation, if he does not see it or comprehend it currently, is to rid himself of the flawed moral heuristic some result-driven, sin-justifying ideologue has chosen which may be blinding him to what is an obvious moral and political truth.

-----
Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas.  He is married with three children.  He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum.  You can contact Andrew at agreenwell@harris-greenwell.com.

---


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'


Copyright 2016 - Distributed by THE CALIFORNIA NETWORK

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for NOVEMBER 2016
Universal:
Countries Receiving Refugees: That the countries which take in a great number of displaced persons and refugees may find support for their efforts which show solidarity.
Evangelization: Collaboration of Priests and Laity: That within parishes, priests and lay people may collaborate in service to the community without giving in to the temptation of discouragement.



Comments


More Marriage & Family

Homeless but never without a home - Man honored by hundreds of mourners at funeral Watch

Image of Thomas Myron Hooker may have been homeless but he was far from being without a home.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Hundreds came together at a San Francisco church to honor the passing of a beloved parishioner. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Thomas Myron Hooker was homeless the last twenty years of his life.He attended the Star of the Sea Catholic Church, where he could be ... continue reading


Love 'til the very end - Elderly man dies while attempting to revive wife Watch

Image of By the time emergency responders reached the couple (not pictured), they were both already gone.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Johnny Hatley discovered his wife of 31 years on the floor of their home in Stanly County, North Carolina on Sunday. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Teresa Ann Brooks Hatley was unresponsive, prompting her frightened husband to attempt CPR.According to Stanly News ... continue reading


12 Advent prayers to share with your family Watch

Image of Try these twelve prayers for the Christmas season.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Every December people are ready to pull out the Christmas decorations, buy and decorate a tree, wrap presents for one another and offer beautiful prayers - but what prayers should you share with your family this year? LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Remember, ... continue reading


Heartbroken woman attacked online after desperate attempts to find daughter via social media Watch

Image of Heartbroken mother desperately searches for daughter.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Rowena Fuller became pregnant as a young teen and at 17-years-old had her daughter taken from her. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - In an act of desperation, the now 59-year-old took to Facebook to find her little girl she named Nicola."#findnicolabrett," she wrote. ... continue reading


WATCH miraculous moment baby wakes from coma days after doctors tried to turn off life support Watch

Image of Marwa woke form a coma after doctors worried about her survival (jamaissansmarwa/Facebook).

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

One-year-old Marwa was placed on life support after contracting a deadly brain-damaging virus. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - According to The Sun, the tiny tot was struck with the virus in September.Marwa's body was so brutally ravaged by the virus that doctors ... continue reading


86-year-old cancer patient gives premature babies over 300 hand-knit hats Watch

Image of Ed Moseley taught himself to knit, so he could make hats for premature babies.

By Abigail James (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Eighty-six year old, Ed Moseley has helped impact the lives of over 300 premature babies and their families. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Despite his cancer diagnosis, Ed taught himself how to knit so that he could provide special warm tiny hats to local babies. ... continue reading


Bless Friday takes on greedy Black Friday with the power of Christ's love Watch

Image of

By Abigail James (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Black Friday is notably one of the largest shopping days of the year. Millions of people gather in front of stores, often camping out, to be among the first to get their hands on the best sales deals.  LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Black Friday turns even ... continue reading


Election disagreements leave some guests uninvited from Thanksgiving dinner Watch

Image of Thanksgiving is canceled for some.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Many people have shared their political views over social media during the intense presidential debates and ensuing election - but what impact has it had on their families? LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - We've all heard, or perhaps even been the victims of losing ... continue reading


4-year-old girl dies after photograph of the real face of cancer goes viral - Join us in prayer for Jessica Whelan and her family Watch

Image of Jessica has passed on to be with our Heavenly Father.

By Kenya Sinclair (CALIFORNIA NETWORK)

Jessica Whelen, a beautiful 4-year-old girl who made headlines earlier this month, has passed away. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Jessica Whelan became the face of cancer when her father took an iconic picture of her pain while being treated for ... continue reading


Pope Francis speaks to bishops about compassion for those suffering broken marriages Watch

Image of Pope Francis tells bishops to have compassion for those who divorce.

By Elise Harris (CNA/EWTN News)

On Friday Pope Francis stopped by a formation course for bishops on the new marriage nullity process, telling attendees that as bishops, and now as local judges in annulment cases, they must pursue the truth, but never exclude those whose marriages have failed. Vatican ... continue reading


All Marriage & Family News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Subscribe to Catholic OnlineYouTube Channel

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Isaiah 11:1-10
1 A shoot will spring from the stock of Jesse, a new shoot will grow from ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 72:1-2, 7-8, 12-13, 17
1 [Of Solomon] God, endow the king with your own fair judgement, the son ... Read More

Gospel, Matthew 3:1-12
1 In due course John the Baptist appeared; he proclaimed this message in ... Read More

Reading 2, Romans 15:4-9
4 And all these things which were written so long ago were written so ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for December 4th, 2016 Image

St. John of Damascus
December 4: Saint John Damascene has the double honor of ... Read More