• HOME
  • MOST POPULAR
  • EMAIL
  • NEWSLETTERS
  • SHOPPING
  • BOOKSTORE
  • TRAVEL
  • VIDEO
Weather | RSS  |  Advertisers
Catholic Online

| U.S. News

catholic.org Web
View Comments  Comments
Email this Article  Email this Article
Printer-Friendly  Printer-Friendly
Letters to Editor  Letters to Editor
Professor Doug Kmiec Endorses Barack Obama
By Professor Doug Kmiec
3/25/2008

Slate Magazine (www.slate.com/)

No doubt some of my friends will see this as a matter of party or intellectual treachery. I regret that and I respect their disagreement.

Advertisement
LOS ANGELES (Catholic Online) - “Today I endorse Barack Obama for president of the United States. I believe him to be a person of integrity, intelligence and genuine good will.

I take him at his word that he wants to move the nation beyond its religious and racial divides and to return United States to that company of nations committed to human rights. I do not know if his earlier life experience is sufficient for the challenges of the presidency that lie ahead. I doubt we know this about any of the men or women we might select. It likely depends upon the serendipity of the events that cannot be foreseen.

I do have confidence that the Senator will cast his net widely in search of men and women of diverse, open-minded views and of superior intellectual qualities to assist him in the wide range of responsibilities that he must superintend.

This endorsement may be of little note or consequence, except perhaps that it comes from an unlikely source: namely, a former constitutional legal counsel to two Republican presidents. The endorsement will likely supply no strategic advantage equivalent to that represented by the very helpful accolades the Senator has received from many of high stature and accomplishment, including most recently, from Governor Bill Richardson.

Nevertheless, it is important to be said publicly in a public forum in order that it be understood. It is not arrived at without careful thought and some difficulty.

As a Republican, I strongly wish to preserve traditional marriage not as a suspicion or denigration of my homosexual friends, but as recognition of the significance of the procreative family as a building block of society.

As a Republican, and as a Catholic, I believe life begins at conception, and it is important for every life to be given sustenance and encouragement.

As a Republican, I strongly believe that the Supreme Court of the United States must be fully dedicated to the rule of law, and to the employ of a consistent method of interpretation that keeps the Court within its limited judicial role.

As a Republican, I believe problems are best resolved closest to their source and that we should never arrogate to a higher level of government that which can be more effectively and efficiently resolved below.

As a Republican, and the constitutional lawyer, I believe religious freedom does not mean religious separation or mindless exclusion from the public square.

In various ways, Senator Barack Obama and I may disagree on aspects of these important fundamentals, but I am convinced based upon his public pronouncements and his personal writing that on each of these questions he is not closed to understanding opposing points of view, and as best as it is humanly possible, he will respect and accommodate them.

No doubt some of my friends will see this as a matter of party or intellectual treachery. I regret that and I respect their disagreement. But they will readily agree that as Republicans, we are first Americans.

As Americans, we must voice our concerns for the well-being of our nation without partisanship when decisions that have been made endanger the body politic.

Our president has involved our nation in a military engagement without sufficient justification or clear objective. In so doing, he has incurred both tragic loss of life and extraordinary debt jeopardizing the economy and the well-being of the average American citizen.

In pursuit of these fatally flawed purposes, the office of the presidency, which it was once my privilege to defend in public office formally, has been distorted beyond its constitutional assignment. Today, I do no more than raise the defense of that important office anew, but as private citizen.

9/11 and the radical Islamic ideology that it represents is a continuing threat to our safety and the next president must have the honesty to recognize that it, as author Paul Berman has written, "draws on totalitarian inspirations from 20th-century Europe and with its double roots, religious and modern, perversely intertwined. . . .wields a lot more power, intellectually speaking, then naïve observers might suppose."

Senator Obama needs to address this extremist movement with the same clarity and honesty with which he has addressed the topic of race in America.

Effective criticism of the incumbent for diverting us from this task is a good start, but it is incomplete without a forthright outline of a commitment to undertake, with international partners, the formation of a world-wide entity that will track, detain, prosecute, convict, punish, and thereby, stem radical Islam's threat to civil order.

I await Senator Obama's more extended thinking upon this vital subject, as he accepts the nomination of his party and engages Senator McCain in the general campaign “



Comments
I read your article supporting California's Propisition 8 and your logic and written word was well done. How can you vote for Obama who is contrary to your core life and family beliefs? The only reason I could see was because you are upset at our current president's choice in regards to Iraq. To risk placing liberal judges in the supreme court by supporting Obama to me is too high of a cost for the unborn and family.
Caryn Harris | 10/14/2008
I am so grateful for Doug Kmiec's honesty, for a man full of faith and reason discerned through prayer and the power of the Holy Spirit. These political choices are not easy for any of us to make. Anyone who says it IS easy, I believe, is deluded by the "whitewashed tombs" and the hearts of pompous candidates who promise yet never deliver after elections. I do not hate any candidate, but I do intensely disagree with the partisan way by which we seem to be bamboozled under the disguise of pro-life issues. Wake up,
Church! Jesus knows each man and woman's heart. Let's choose the one for our country who is not campaigning because he thinks he deserves it for past service, but the one whose heart is with the people, for the people--for the right reason, to make a positive difference in the lives of ALL people, not just the rich and famous. The Truth sets us free! If we truly keep our eyes fixed on the Lord, it's difficult to vote for someone who loves money more than God and people. Jesus never fails!
Val | 9/18/2008
Endorsing someone that is opposed to the fundamental positions you have, not as a Republican, but as core beliefs is troubling. I pray that you and the Ted Kennedy's and Joe Biden's of our faith are not representative of the moral equivalence with which we determine political choices. How any Catholic can pull a lever for Pro Choice candidates is beyond me. Barack Obama is an extremist on right-to-life issues as proven in his thrice voting against supporting aid for a newborn that survives an abortion. Barack Obama does not support the right to life, Supreme Court justices in the mold of Roberts or Thomas nor the fundamental structure of the United States as a non-socialist country. Your endorsement flies in the face of the principles of Ronald Reagan who held to his integrity and conviction without agreeing that core beliefs can be compromised for political expediency. While you may have sold your soul for pieces of silver in support of your new 'chosen one' I will continue to pray for real salvation for all and not compromise my beliefs for political purposes. You illustrate that you are endorsing someone that has such diametrically opposed core beliefs from you and our shared faith. My heart is heavy that so many of our brethren may prostitute themselves as well.
David | 9/5/2008
Post your Comment
Comments that include profanity, personal attacks, antisocial behavior such as "spamming" and "trolling," or other inappropriate comments or material will not be posted on Catholic Online. Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. We will take steps to block users who violate any of our terms of service. While Catholic Online invites robust discussion, we maintain the right to not print material that is patently false in its claims concerning the teaching of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church, overtly anti-Catholic or which, in the opinion of the moderator, are intended to mislead readers as to what the Catholic Church teaches. Comments DO NOT necessarily reflect the opinion or views of Catholic Online.
Name:


Email:


Comments:





RATE THIS
Was this helpful to you? Would you like to see more on this subject?
Very Helpful Yes, I am Interested
Somewhat Helpful No, I am not Interested
Not Helpful at All


NEWSLETTERS »

E-mail Address:    Gender:    Zip Code: (ex. 90001)

Today's Headlines
Sign up for a roundup of the day's top stories. 5 days / week. See Sample



Un Minuto con María - Esposa del Espíritu Santo
Feb 09 - Homily: The Dwelling Place of the Lord
A Tradition of Good Help
Today's Headlines - News by E-Mail
Sign up for a roundup of the day's top stories. 5 days / week. See Sample
  
  1. Reading 1, 1 Kgs 8:22-23, 27-30
    Then, in the presence of the whole assembly of Israel, Solomon stood facing the altar of ... More »
  2. Gospel, Mk 7:1-13
    The Pharisees and some of the scribes who had come from Jerusalem gathered round him, More »
SHARE & BOOKMARK

MORE U.S. NEWS »
MOST POPULAR »
Receive the Challenge…Be inspired!
By Glenmary Home Missioners
Glenmary Challenge, the quarterly magazine of Glenmary Home Missioners, opens up the world of the U.S. home missions to readers ...
 
Looking for something unique? We import the best from around the world - handcrafted rosaries, bracelets, pendants, books, and ...

News | Featured | Finance | A & E | Home & Family | PRWire | Encyclopedia | Bible | Prayers | Vocations | Saints & Angels | Life | Books | Directory | Services
Copyright 2010 Catholic Online. All materials contained on this site, whether written, audible or visual are the exclusive property of
Catholic Online and are protected under U.S. and International copyright laws, © Copyright 2010 Catholic Online. Any unauthorized
use, without prior written consent of Catholic Online is strictly forbidden and prohibited.