Skip to main content


Text of talk by Vatican Observatory director on ‘Science Does Not Need God. Or Does It? A Catholic Scientist Looks at Evolution’

1/30/2006

(Page 2 of 3)

found in modern science.

I would like now to address some of these issues by demonstrating with a series of slides the best modern scientific view of the universe in evolution: physical, chemical and biological. As a Christian believer I would then like to draw some implications from the science presented. The following text represents the essentials of that presentation.

The Cosmos and Life

How is a star born? It happens by the laws of physics. A cloud of gas and dust, containing about 100 to 1,000 times the mass of our sun, gets shocked by a supernova explosion or something similar and this causes an interplay between the magnetic and gravity fields. The cloud begins to break up and chunks of the cloud begin to collapse. And as any gas collapses, it begins to heat up; as it expands, it cools down. In this case the mass is so great that the internal temperature reaches millions of degrees and thus turns on a thermonuclear furnace. A star is born. Thermonuclear energy is the source whereby a star radiates to the universe. You need a very hot piece of the universe to do this, and so you can only get this thermonuclear furnace by having a cloud collapse and raise the temperature. You can only get it, in other words, in stars, with one exception, namely, in the very hot early universe before galaxies or stars were born.

Stars also die. A star at the end of its life can no longer sustain a thermonuclear furnace and so it can no longer resist against gravity. It collapses for a final time, explodes and expels its outer atmosphere to the universe. This may happen nice and peacefully or it may happen in a violent cataclysmic explosion, called a supernova. The most famous of these is the Crab Nebula which has a pulsar at the middle as its dead star.

So stars are born and stars die. And as they die they spew left over star matter out to the universe. The birth and death of stars is very important. If it were not happening, you and I would not be here, and that is a scientific fact. In order to get the chemical elements to make the human body, we had to have three generations of stars. A succeeding generation of stars is born out of the material that is spewed out by a previous generation. But now notice that the second generation of stars is born out of material that was made in a thermonuclear furnace. The star lived by converting hydrogen to helium, helium to carbon, and if it were massive enough, carbon to oxygen, to nitrogen, all the way up to iron. As a star lives, it converts the lighter elements into the heavier elements. That is the way we get carbon and silicon and the other elements to make human hair and toe nails and all of those things. To get the chemistry to make amoebas we had to have the stars regurgitating material to the universe.

Obviously this story of star birth and death is very important for us. Out of this whole process around one star, which we call the sun, a group of planets came to be, among them the little grain of sand we call the Earth. An amazing thing happened with that little grain of sand when, in the 16th and 17th centuries with the birth of modern science, we developed the capacity to put the universe in our heads. We do that by using mathematics and physics, and to some extent the laws of chemistry and biology. Since we have the capacity to put the universe in our heads, further questions come to us, even some, as we shall see, which go beyond science.

How did we humans come to be in this evolving universe? It is quite clear that we do not know everything about this process. But it would be scientifically absurd to deny that the human brain is a result of a process of chemical complexification in an evolving universe. After the universe became rich in certain basic chemicals, those chemicals got together in successive steps to make ever more complex molecules.

Finally in some extraordinary chemical process the human brain came to be, the most complicated machine that we know. I should make it clear that, when I speak about the human brain as a machine, I am not excluding the spiritual dimension of the human being. I am simply prescinding from it and talking about the human brain as a biological, chemical mechanism, evolving out of the universe.

Chance or Design

Did this happen by chance or by necessity in this evolving universe? Was it destined to happen? The first thing to be said is that the problem is not formulated correctly. It is not just a question of chance or necessity because, first of all, it is both. Furthermore, there is a third element here that is very important. It is what I call “fertility” or “opportunity.” What this means is that the universe is so prolific in offering the opportunity for the success of both chance and necessary processes that such a character of the universe must be included in the discussion. The universe is 13.7 billion years old, ...

Rate This Article

Very Helpful Somewhat Helpful Not Helpful at All

Yes, I am Interested No, I am not Interested

Rate Article

1 - 6 of 6 Comments

  1. Mary Brune- Burke
    1 year ago

    This article is so well thought out and based on Scientific research and a life of questioning.
    I appreciated this as an intelligent thinker and it makes me believe in God more now than being expected to believe just out of a trust or Faith alone.

  2. Immanuel Fajgel
    2 years ago

    This is ... finally ... a christian answer to the problems posed by the theory of evolution that I can actually respect as plausible.
    I am, myself an atheist, and as such do not believe in the idea this article throws up.
    But I consider it possible, even though I really don't see a reason to believe in it myself.
    Responding to the bible-waving comments posted above, I believe the mistake many people make is to take the bible literally instead of philosophically.
    It's fairly obvious that the Book of Genesis, for example, is simply the attempt of 2000 B.C.- humans to explain the origins of the universe. It can't be taken seriously.
    But there is still a lot we can learn from the bible to help us evolve if we look in the right places with the right mindset.

  3. Jonathan CHM
    4 years ago

    Genesis 1:27, "So God made man in his own image".
    Genesis 2:7, "And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground."
    Genesis 2:21-22, "And the Lord God caused a deep sleep to fall upon Adam, …the Lord had taken from man, made he a woman, & brought her unto the man".
    From the above verses, it is obvious that God formed man/woman from dust instead of transforming apes to human beings.

  4. Mark Fernandes
    4 years ago

    Dear Fr. George V. Coyne,

    I'm afraid I have to agree with Mark Germine's comments.

    From our catholic faith we believe in miracles; for example the resurrection of our Lord, or the turning of water into wine by our Lord. These miracles do not simply happen in a 'theological world' different to reality - they happen in reality, and have an effect on reality. We, as the Church, must believe in these miracles. Now if we ignore the possibility of miracles from our scientific data, we are essentially doing a kind of biased science, not true science. We can therefore not separate science from our catholic faith.

    Imagine trying to separate the world of fashion from religion; you would then possibly turn out some very immoral fashions; or imagine trying to separate religion from medicine; you would then possibly turn out some rather immoral medical practices. Religion has an impact on everything, and I think it is immoral to try to live otherwise - I believe science has become something of a false god, and I don't think trying to separate science in the way that you seem to propose helps.

    Personally, I am very skeptical about the certainity with which scientists believe their theories are true - maybe they are true, but I think we should not discard Sacred Scripture from science. This, I believe, is a grave error.

    Kind regards,

    Mark

  5. Grace Carroll
    4 years ago

    I thought this was an excellent article.

  6. Mark Germine, MD, MS
    4 years ago

    Beloved,

    I do not believe that science and religion are totally separate pursuits. Science has embraced a materialism which is inimitable to any kind of spirituality. If God can have no effect on the world or on our own being then this goes against the teachings, if He can, then we have entered into the realm of science, be it in evolution or in our own minds. With the latter intent in mind, that mind is enlivened by spirit, I have started Psychoscience: The Journal of Mind and Spirit: http://psychocience.com

    I deeply believe that the spirit of God dwells within us, in our minds, and that, as Alfred North Whitehead said "God is the infinite source of all mentality." I have felt this in my own mind; I have experienced it. The theory of mind is most definitely in the realm of science.

    Mark Germine, MD, MS

Leave a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws including copyright. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion.

Though we invite robust discussion, we reserve the right to not publish any comment which denigrates the human person, undermines marriage and the family, or advocates for positions which openly oppose the teaching of the Catholic Church.

This is a supervised forum and the Editors of Catholic Online retain the right to direct it.

We also reserve the right to block any commenter for repeated violations. Your email address is required to post, but it will not be published on the site.

We ask that you NOT post your comment more than once. Catholic Online is growing and our ability to review all comments sometimes results in a delay in their publication.

Send me important information from Catholic Online and it's partners. See Sample

Post Comment


Newsletter Sign Up

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Sirach 5:1-8
Do not put your confidence in your money or say, 'With this I ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 1:1-2, 3-4, 6
How blessed is anyone who rejects the advice of the wicked and ... Read More

Gospel, Mark 9:41-50
'If anyone gives you a cup of water to drink because you belong ... Read More

Saint of the Day

May 23 Saint of the Day

St. John Baptist Rossi
May 23: This holy priest was born in 1698 at the village of Voltaggio in ... Read More




Marketplace

Click Here

Come and See: The Gospel of John
The Scripture scholarship of Father Joseph Ponessa and the teaching ... Read More


Click Here

Pope francis Bronze Canvas Print
Read More