Skip to main content

The Heart's Witness Against Muhammad: The Quartering of Umm Qirfa Comments

Is Muhammad's encouragement of this war ethic, and his participation in the capture and trading of women, and in their brutal killing, a perfection to imitate?  A normal man, heeding his conscience, listening to reason, and trained in virtue, would find such behavior abhorrent, against the letter and the spirit of the natural moral law.  But he who has been taught that Muhammad is the perfect man, al-insan al-kamil, and the uswatun ... Continue Reading

11 - 15 of 15 Comments

  1. Andrew M. Greenwell
    2 years ago

    @KarlVDH: I appreciate your comments, but would make one point. You never really take issue with what the articles say. Instead, you depart from the article and start talking about something else (the Old Testament, Church history, etc., etc.) and find fault there. It is as if you think that deflecting the argument is a legitimate argument against Muhammad as the perfect man and moral example.

    The argument, however, is fallacious. And on two grounds, one formal, one material.

    Formally, the argument is called a tu quoque argument. It blames the speaker and avoids what is being spoken. It is a well-known fallacy.

    Besides, you miss the essential point of this series, and so commit a material fallacy. Whatever faults OT characters and Christians have, none have (supposedly) been designated by God as al-insan al-kamil, "the perfect man," uswa hasana, "the perfect example." This view of Muhammad is supposedly divinely revealed and is both explicitly and implicitly part of the Islamic worldview. See Qur΄an, 33:21, 3:32, 3:132, 4:13, 4:59, 4:69, 4:80, 5:92, 8:1, 8:20, 8:46, 9:71, 24:47, 24:51, 24:52, 24:54, 24:56, 33:33, 47:33, 49:14, 64:12, 68:4. An orthodox Muslim is compelled to see Muhammad as perfect. There is absolutely no way to deny this. It is as essential to Islam as the Trinity or the Incarnation is to Christians.

    Finally, I find it ironic for you to say that you cannot find Jesus in these articles when the whole end of this particular article is a sort of coda praising the Lord Jesus as the Prince of Peace and a prayer for the conversion of Muslims.

  2. Mrs. Rene O'Riordan
    2 years ago

    Thanks again Andrew. So few Catholics are aware of the incompatibility of islam with Christianity I have been posting these on facebook - and of course the reaction from my muslims are of anger. But my hope is some will begin to question what they have been told all their life long. I believe they are held captive by fear - fear of the hell promised by mohommad, fear of losing their own life if they question, fear of losing all their family and friends. Much prayer and fasting is needed. We are in such a time of great opportunity to reach out to them (without getting the head cut off). Again thanks - Rene

  3. Cuthbert Efeotor
    2 years ago

    This article is very reviling to some of us that are not privileged to read religion history books. I have come to realised that must human in this present generation only practice religion not for their salvation but for earthly relationship (Belonging to the known in this earth) So would do all within their ability to defend their believe or faith.
    It is one with God and God for all.
    But not we with God and God for we.
    No one fight for God, instead God fights for his faithful people.
    By my understanding, individual will be facing God judgment one for himself but not in groups of settlement or of religions or in teams.
    We continue to pray that God will open our heart to know, learn and teach his salvation.
    By salvation, I mean saving your soul. Believing your soul will have a place in God's kingdom after ones earthly existence.

  4. shelly.
    2 years ago

    make more article like this.It is very useful to realize all Muslims and non muslms about the true profile of Islam.

  5. KarlVDH
    2 years ago

    Come on, folks!! Why are we afraid to discuss this stuff honestly?? Our own Bible contains verses that, if we applied the same strict, literalistic standarsd we apply to Koranic passages, ALSO demands- by command of God- the slaughter of the conquered, the taking of war booty, the rape of female captives, and wholesale destruction. It's THERE. But we all realize it's not necessarily God's word for how to behave today. But we pretend that every Muslim the world over appliees this twisted literal standard to their own faith. WHY??? It's simply not true.
    And our OWN Church's history is absolutely RIFE with our OWN history of bloodshed, torture, and flat out EVIL committed in God's name. But we pretend it's never happened. We pretend Western meddling in middle eastern affairs throughout history from India to Baghdad to today hasn't happened, and paint them as mindless, fanatical aggressors, while ignoring the long history our cultures have had of MUTUAL wrongs.
    And now that I've said so, no doubt, the best I can expect as a rebuttal will be some foolish accusation of being a Muslim myself. The truth is I'm not, I'm just honest enough to see this series of articles for what it really is. It's answering whet we see as hate from the Jihadists by justifying our own hatred, it gowes DIRECTLY against the specific teaching of the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church, and Christ simply isn't in it. Where are the calls for prayer for Muslims? Prayers for PEACE rather than deliberately using fear and prejudice to strengthening the walls of division and enmity that already exist? Why is it so hard to find Jesus in these articles?
    Now go ahead and call me a Muslim and be done with it.

Leave a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws including copyright. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion.

Though we invite robust discussion, we reserve the right to not publish any comment which denigrates the human person, undermines marriage and the family, or advocates for positions which openly oppose the teaching of the Catholic Church.

This is a supervised forum and the Editors of Catholic Online retain the right to direct it.

We also reserve the right to block any commenter for repeated violations. Your email address is required to post, but it will not be published on the site.

We ask that you NOT post your comment more than once. Catholic Online is growing and our ability to review all comments sometimes results in a delay in their publication.

Send me important information from Catholic Online and it's partners. See Sample

Post Comment

Newsletter Sign Up

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Deuteronomy 26:16-19
'Yahweh your God commands you today to observe these laws and ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 119:1-2, 4-5, 7-8
How blessed are those whose way is blameless, who walk in the ... Read More

Gospel, Matthew 5:43-48
'You have heard how it was said, You will love your neighbour ... Read More

Saint of the Day

February 28 Saint of the Day

St. Hilary, Pope
February 28: Pope from 461-468 and guardian of Church unity. He was born in ... Read More