Skip to main content


Cromwell and communists banned Christmas, too

On Oct. 4, the US Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal on the ban on "celebratory religious music" upheld by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in the South Orange-Maplewood district in New Jersey. Parents and opponents organized an "illegal" night of Christmas and Hanukkah festivities.


TORONTO, ON (The Interim) - On Oct. 4, the US Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal on the ban on "celebratory religious music" upheld by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in the South Orange-Maplewood district in New Jersey. The issue was first raised in 2004 when a parent sued the school board after it issued a memo before its December concert clarifying its ban on religious songs in performances, a policy enacted in the 1990s. Parents and opponents organized an "illegal" night of Christmas and Hanukkah festivities. Before the memo was issued, Christmas carols were sung in school concerts.

On Sept. 9, in Virginia, the Loudon County Board of Supervisors upheld a policy allowing unattended displays on the grounds of the courthouse after a resident-led commission advocated its ban. According to the commission, this was due to the  rising demand for limited space. Public outrage was sparked after the commission denied an application to put a Christmas tree on the court grounds.

The removal of Christmas references is a well-known phenomenon throughout North America, and is typically justified in the name of 'inclusion.' Advocates do not want to 'impose' a particular religious holiday on another group, in the name of tolerance. These instances of political correctness are commonly followed by a public outcry.

Toronto has had its own Christmas controversies. In 2002, officials from city hall published a news release in which they referred to the Christmas tree at Nathan Phillips Square a "holiday tree." After public backlash, Mayor Mel Lastman, ordered city staff to call it a Christmas tree and then introduced a bylaw preventing it from being named anything else.

Christmas controversies continued in Canada's largest and most multicultural city. In 2006, Justice Marion Cohen ordered that a Christmas tree be removed from a provincial courthouse at 311 Jarvis St. She wrote in a letter to employees that non-Christians are "confronted" with the tree which made them feel as if "they are not part of the institution." Premier Dalton McGuinty then spoke out against her decision as unfair to one group's traditions: "At Queen's Park we celebrated Diwali a few weeks ago, as well at Queen's Park we celebrated Eid. Next week I believe I'm participating in a lighting of the menorah celebration," he said. "What we're saying is, let's share these opportunities, let's better understand those celebrations." After the outcry, the tree was moved to an administrative corridor.

There are now several campaigns to protect and recall the true meaning of Christmas and its traditions. In the United States, Focus on the Family, the Liberty Counsel and the American Family Association each compile blacklists of retailers who do not acknowledge Christmas in their advertisements In Canada, the Knights of Columbus' 'Keep Christ in Christmas' campaign encourages Catholics to spread awareness of the real meaning of Christmas.

There is also an awareness that the growing commercialization of Christmas is usurping its original meaning. Owing to this, German Catholics belonging to a church aid organization, Bonifatiuswerk, have reacted by advocating "Santa Claus-free zones." Santa Claus is, to them, "an invention of the advertising industry designed to boost sales," and "a representation of consumer society [which] has little to do with the historical figure of St. Nicolas." They seek to replace this popular image with that of St. Nicolas, who emphasizes inner as opposed to material wealth.

Santa Claus, though, has also been the victim of overt political correctness. At Christmas time last year, Australia's Monash University published a study in the British Medical Journal condemning the figure of Santa Claus as a negative role model for children. The authors inform readers that "there is a correlation between countries that venerate Santa Claus and those that have high levels of childhood obesity," and it is possible that "Santa promotes a message that obesity is synonymous with cheerfulness and joviality." Therefore, say the study's authors, Santa ought to go on a diet, be left celery and carrot sticks instead of cookies, and find a more active mode of transport than a sleigh.

Unfortunately, the idea of reconstructing a traditional image to create a state-sanctioned role model has been used before by far less of a benevolent regime. Before becoming president, Ronald Reagan used his radio broadcasts to attack the anti-Christmas action of communist leaders in the Soviet Union. He said Moscow, "eventually began banning Christmas commemorations," as "St. Nicholas was replaced with Did Moroz, or Grandfather Frost. This Stalinist creation wears a red cap and long white beard of Santa Claus, but he delivers gifts to children on New Year's Eve. Christmas trees were also banned, but people continued to trim their New Year's trees. Communism folded all Christmas celebrations into a New Year celebration." Before Christmas traditions were adapted to New Year celebrations, the traditional Russian fir tree was banned and Grandfather Frost, the Russian form of Santa or St. Nicolas, was "unmasked as an ally of the priest and kulak," according to Karen Petrone, author of Life has Become More Joyous, Comrades: Celebrations in the Time of Stalin.

In the early years of New Year's Day festivities, production was especially emphasized, as workers were entertained by reports of the productivity of the worst workshop with street organ music playing in the background. A brigade from the Meierkhol'd Theatre sang to workers in a Moscow factory, "if 1,000 people were to choose not to come to work on a religious holiday it would cost the factory 48,000 rubles." As the need came to increase the morale of the Russian citizenry, New Years began to be celebrated as more of a form of pure enjoyment shorn of religious significance and national elements were incorporated.

The U.S.S.R., though, was not the first country to ban Christmas. In 1647, the Puritan-dominated English Parliament passed a law abolishing the holiday. Under Oliver Cromwell's rule following the execution of Charles I, Christmas customs, services, and festivities were prohibited. This sparked riots and people were jailed for defiance of the law. The Puritans thought Christmas encouraged English debauchery during feasting. They also suspected Christmas of being an expression of Catholicism, as the holiday was, in fact, called "Christ's Mass" and not decreed in the Bible. Christmas was therefore called Christ Tide and declared a day of fasting and prayer. It was only reinstated after the Restoration in the 1660s.

British bishops and the Vatican are now worried that Christmas will be banned again in the name of not offending people of other faiths and convictions. The Equality Act, which came into force this October in Britain, could pose a significant threat to the autonomy of religious institutions in a secular country seeking to impose its values on others. "Under existing legislation we have seen the development of a risk-averse culture with outcomes as ridiculous as reports of a local authority instructing tenants to take down Christmas lights in case they might offend Muslim neighbours, or of authorities removing the word Christmas out of cultural sensitivity to everyone except Christians," said the Catholic Bishops Conference of England and Wales in its evidence presented before a parliamentary committee examining the bill in November 2009. "If this bill is serious about equality, everything possible must be done to avoid it having a 'chilling' effect on religious expression and practice."

Concerns about equality and not offending others often run only one way. In 2008, Home Depot eschewed use of the term Christmas on their website, while employing Hanukkah in its holiday advertising. Several years earlier, the Miami Herald wished a Happy Hanukkah in the days before Christmas on its banner and a Happy Kwanza on its front page on Dec. 26, but did not wish a Merry Christmas to its Christian readers anywhere in its pages. In 2005, Lowe's used the term holiday tree to advertise their Christmas trees in English but used árboles de Navidad (Christmas tree) in their Spanish advertising. In 2007, Lowe's began selling "Family Trees."

Successful campaigns against avoiding the use of Christmas in commercial advertising have resulted in numerous chains including Sears, K-Mart and the Gap to reinsert Christmas messaging and acknowledging the Christmas gift-giving season rather than the holiday gift-giving season.

While authorities and corporations continue to try to ban any vestige of religious observance or acknowledgement, the public continues to pushback, defending Christmas trees, carols, and expressions of good wishes. A generation after the politically correct term Happy Holidays was inserted into the public conversation, a large number of Christians are still resisting. Many public officials are backing down and many companies are reversing course. But, as Tom Fleming of Chronicles magazine wrote a decade ago, the war against Christmas is at heart battle for the soul of society, secular versus religious. It is yet another battleground in the culture wars.

© 2010, The Interim. Distributed by NEWS CONSORTIUM.

---

The Interim is Canada’s life and family issues newspaper. Since it was founded in 1983, The Interim has provided honest reporting and insightful commentary on abortion, euthanasia, bioethics, family values and marriage.

Keywords: Christmas, culture, secularism, religion, saints, communism, Puritanism



NEWSLETTERS »

E-mail:       Zip Code: (ex. 90001)
Today's Headlines

Sign up for a roundup of the day's top stories. 5 days / week. See Sample

Rate This Article

Very Helpful Somewhat Helpful Not Helpful at All

Yes, I am Interested No, I am not Interested

Rate Article

1 - 6 of 6 Comments

  1. Bulbajer
    3 years ago

    Good article. I love Santa, both the cultural icon and the real saint, but the commercial image has overshadowed the other two. Santa first became obese ("thick-boned", as a relative of mine would say) as recently as the 19th century, and Coca-Cola popularized his modern image.
    I remember a children's book that went like this: Santa Claus feels ashamed that the modern world has forgotten the true meaning of Christmas. He thinks he is the problem. He prays in front of a manger scene, and little Baby Jesus thanks him for his devotion to the love of God and humanity.

  2. Harold Olsen
    3 years ago

    The anti-Christmas sentiment seems to be getting worse this year, if it hadn't been bad enough in recent years. Everyone seems to have a need to be politically correct. No "Merry Christmas" just "Happy Holidays." You know it's really getting bad when supposed Christian organizations become politically correct. Last year was the first time I ever dropped money into a Salvation Army bucket. I had planned on doing it again this year. Several days ago, as I approached the bell ringer, he greeted me, not with "Merry Christmas" but with "Happy Holidays." I walked past him without putting anything in his bucket. When a supposed Christian organization becomes politically correct, they get no donations from me.

  3. Andy Holland
    3 years ago

    Our Bill of Rights is ruble - when the 1st Amendment was passed States had established religions and there were religious services held in the House. The first Amendment, the freedom to speak even to God when and where We the People so choose without Federal interference is now meaningless. And this because of a few chosen ones who wear Priestly robes and meet in State funded temples surrounded by neo-pagan art and architecture. They even demand human sacrifice, aborted babies! Those poor Priests of Molech will reap what they have sown; there is no prison in this world suitable for their punishment for crimes against the Lord God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Innocents, and the established written laws they swore oaths to uphold and defend.

  4. daniel shatuuck
    3 years ago

    remember christ and god win the battle

  5. Paul James Nagy
    3 years ago

    Better to "impose" symbols of Christianity with love than impose images etc. of Islam by way of the sword. Politically incorrect ? Too bad.

    As for feeding Santa Clause celery and carrots - Yech ! I am sure he eats properly all year long and a few disaccharides on Christmas Eve won't hurt the old guy. Besides he's a saint and some extra weight (as we know it) won't hurt him.

  6. Jake Allsop
    3 years ago

    I do not celebrate Divali or Hannukah or Eid or the Chinese New Year, but I have no problem if others want to make public declarations of their faith, just as long as I am allowed to make a public declaration of mine. I wish everyone, Catholic and non-Catholic alike, a Happy and Peaceful Christmas and a Blessed New Year. And I thank my Turkish Muslim friends who always wish me "Iyi bayramlar" (on the occasion of Eid el Fitr and Eid el Kabir).

Leave a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws including copyright. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion.

Though we invite robust discussion, we reserve the right to not publish any comment which denigrates the human person, undermines marriage and the family, or advocates for positions which openly oppose the teaching of the Catholic Church.

This is a supervised forum and the Editors of Catholic Online retain the right to direct it.

We also reserve the right to block any commenter for repeated violations. Your email address is required to post, but it will not be published on the site.

We ask that you NOT post your comment more than once. Catholic Online is growing and our ability to review all comments sometimes results in a delay in their publication.

Send me important information from Catholic Online and it's partners. See Sample

Post Comment

Great Christmas Gift Ideas